Kay Volmar’s Journey: Renovating a 1912 Florida Cottage into a Forever Home
Hands-on solutions turned an old home’s surprises into personalized living spaces.

Kay Volmar’s Renovation Story: Bringing a 1912 Florida Cottage Back to Life
Kay Volmar, the creative force behind the celebrated home transformation blog, undertook the ambitious project of restoring a historic 1912 Florida cottage into her beloved forever home. Featured on Better Homes & Gardens’ podcast The Better Buy, Kay’s journey is a testament to the power of patience, positivity, and intentional design when taking on a major home renovation.
Introduction to the Home and the Journey
This cottage was more than just a structure; it was a vessel for Kay’s vision, resilience, and unwavering optimism. Facing the challenges inherent in renovating a century-old home, Kay navigated surprises, setbacks, and discoveries that would ultimately shape not just her living space, but her approach to design and life.
- Historical charm: Embracing the architectural quirks and the legacy of the 1912 cottage.
- Personalization: Each design decision reflected Kay’s personality and values.
- DIY determination: Tackling projects hands-on, often learning new skills as she went.
Why Kay Chose the Cottage: The Inspiration Behind the Forever Home
For Kay, choosing this particular 1912 Florida cottage was a soul-driven decision. She was captivated by its weatherworn beauty and the stories it held within its walls. More than potential resale value or curb appeal, Kay was motivated by the opportunity to craft a home that authentically expressed her journey and spirit.
Core Motivations
- Historic character: The cottage offered unique details and craftsmanship that new builds couldn’t replicate.
- Emotional connection: Kay felt an immediate bond, envisioning a cozy, personalized oasis.
- Space for creativity: She saw the cottage as a blank canvas awaiting transformation.
Patience and Positivity: Keys to Renovation Success
Throughout her renovation, Kay emphasized that patience and positivity were non-negotiable. The process of restoring an old cottage meant navigating unexpected issues—from structural repairs to sourcing materials for vintage details.
- Delays and disappointment were reframed as opportunities for creative solutions.
- Maintaining a positive outlook kept momentum going during difficult phases.
- Kay cultivated a growth mindset, embracing each setback as a lesson.
Design Strategies: Honoring History While Infusing Personal Style
Kay approached the cottage’s design with conscious intention: she wanted to retain the charm and authenticity of the home’s original era, while infusing it with elements that reflected her own modern taste and lifestyle needs.
Balancing Old and New
- Restoration over replacement: Kay salvaged and restored original moldings, floors, and windows wherever possible, rather than simply replacing them.
- Thoughtful upgrades: She updated plumbing, electrical, and kitchen layouts to accommodate modern living, choosing finishes that complemented the cottage’s vintage character.
- Layered design: The décor balanced classic elements like beadboard walls and clawfoot tubs with fresh paint colors, contemporary lighting, and eclectic art.
The Power of DIY: Tackling Projects Hands-On
A core pillar of Kay’s renovation experience was her willingness to do-it-yourself. She tackled a wide array of projects, from installing new fixtures to re-purposing salvaged materials—gaining new skills, confidence, and a deeper connection to her home with every task.
- DIY helped her stay within budget without compromising on quality or design.
- Her hands-on approach allowed for deeper personalization and immediate problem solving.
- Kay’s willingness to experiment—learning as she went—empowered others to take ownership of their own renovation dreams.
Biggest Lessons Learned Along the Way
Sharing her experience on The Better Buy podcast, Kay outlined the transformative lessons of her cottage restoration:
Lesson | Description |
---|---|
Embrace the Unexpected | Old homes inevitably come with surprises—adaptability is crucial. |
Value Progress Over Perfection | Perfection can stifle progress. Celebrate small wins and incremental improvements. |
Savor the Stories | Every scratch, repair, and detail carries a story worth cherishing. |
Build with Heart | Your home is a reflection of your journey. Make choices you truly love. |
Overcoming Challenges: Renovation Obstacles and Strategies
Restoring an old cottage was as much about troubleshooting as it was about dreaming. Kay encountered numerous roadblocks—many invisible at first glance when purchasing a historic home.
- Structural repairs—from foundation work to roof reinforcement.
- Budget constraints—creative recycling of materials and prioritizing essential renovations.
- Permit and code updates—navigating modern regulation for a century-old structure.
- Supply chain delays—patience required for sourcing vintage and specialty materials.
How Kay Managed the Stress
- She relied on community knowledge, learning from local experts and neighbors familiar with old homes.
- Kay practiced mindfulness to keep perspective through lengthy setbacks.
- She celebrated every milestone—no matter how small—to maintain motivation.
Design Tips from Kay’s Cottage Transformation
Kay’s renovation was filled with clever design tricks that any homeowner can adapt, especially those working with smaller or older spaces.
- Use natural light: Kay maximized the cottage’s windows and enhanced brightness with light wall colors.
- Layer textures: Mixing original wood, new textiles, and found objects added depth and warmth.
- Multipurpose furnishings: Kay selected furniture that could adapt to changing needs—storage ottomans, fold-out tables, etc.
- Preserve architectural details: Let unique elements like transom windows and exposed beams shine as focal points.
- Outdoor living: She enhanced porches and yard space to extend the cottage’s usable area.
Telling the Cottage’s Story: Photography and Social Media
Kay chronicled her renovation journey on her blog and social media, cultivating a community of fellow home enthusiasts and renovators.
- Before and after photos documented progress and celebrated transformation.
- Kay shared tutorials, inspiration boards, and sneak peeks of new projects.
- Her engagement with followers fostered a supportive network where tips and encouragement flowed freely.
Living in a Forever Home: What It Truly Means
For Kay, the phrase forever home is not just about the house itself—it’s about building a life full of memories, comfort, and personal growth. The completed cottage stands as a physical testament to years of effort, creativity, and loving persistence.
- Spaces designed for longevity, comfort, and inspiration.
- Rooms reflect evolving personal style, adapting over time to new interests and needs.
- Home rituals—morning coffee on the porch, evening gatherings—are woven into the cottage’s daily life.
Kay’s Advice for Aspiring Home Renovators
Inspiring others to pursue their own renovation dreams, Kay emphasizes starting where you are and growing as you go.
- Don’t wait for perfection—begin with what you have.
- Take your time to learn new skills and problem solve.
- Surround yourself with inspiration, both online and within your local community.
- Be kind to yourself—mistakes are part of the process, not proof of failure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: What inspired Kay Volmar to purchase and renovate her 1912 Florida cottage?
A: Kay was drawn to the cottage’s historic charm, craftsmanship, and the opportunity to create a deeply personal, authentic forever home.
Q: What were some of the greatest renovation challenges Kay faced?
A: From major structural repairs to budget limitations and modern code requirements, Kay tackled an array of unforeseen issues throughout the project.
Q: How did Kay balance preserving original features with making modern upgrades?
A: Kay prioritized restoring original elements whenever possible, while updating critical systems and design to reflect her current lifestyle and taste.
Q: What lessons can be learned from Kay’s cottage restoration?
A: Patience, positivity, adaptability, and the importance of savoring both progress and setbacks are central tenets of Kay’s approach.
Q: How can homeowners infuse personal style into a historic renovation?
A: Incorporate layered textures, maximize natural light, honor architectural features, and select furnishings that evolve with changing needs.
Conclusion: Building Dreams, One Nail at a Time
Kay Volmar’s 1912 Florida cottage is more than a home—it’s a living chronicle of ambition, resilience, and the transformative power of creative vision. Her journey, detailed in The Better Buy podcast and blog, offers both inspiration and practical guidance for anyone looking to transform a space into their forever haven.
References
- https://fountain.fm/show/5614613
- https://open.spotify.com/episode/5NEvCJbmUjBj6FqgtY8Fo8
- https://open.spotify.com/show/69DOLwIV3dBawVHVwockmS
- https://music.amazon.com/es-cl/podcasts/d2a32505-e3d5-4d3a-baaf-473712cff2c7/the-better-buy
- https://player.fm/series/the-better-buy/dave-and-jenny-marrs-the-story-behind-fixer-to-fabulous
Read full bio of medha deb