Home » Home Improvement » Home Improvement Ideas

Restoring Old Houses: 15 Mistakes Every Homeowner Should Avoid

Expert advice helps preserve your home’s charm and prevents unforeseen setbacks.

By Medha deb

Created on Sep 23, 2025

Expert advice helps preserve your home’s charm and prevents unforeseen setbacks.

Restoring a historic or old house is a journey filled with rewards and challenges. While bringing new life to a period property can result in a truly special home, many owners fall into common traps that can undermine their hard work or even cause lasting harm. By recognizing these critical missteps—from neglecting structural integrity to choosing the wrong paint—homeowners can make smarter decisions and preserve their property’s authenticity, comfort, and value for generations to come.

1. Ignoring Existing Structural Issues

Many old homes harbor hidden structural problems beneath the surface—think sagging beams, settling foundations, or rotting sill plates. Overlooking these issues in favor of cosmetic upgrades can result in significant repair costs and safety risks down the road.

Inspect thoroughly before starting major work—hire qualified structural engineers or restoration specialists.
Address problems like foundation cracks, warped floors, and compromised posts at the outset.
Avoid masking symptoms (like persistently damp walls) without resolving underlying causes such as moisture intrusion or leaks.

2. Poor Paint Selection and Surface Preparation

Paint does more than enhance aesthetics: it also protects wood and masonry from the elements. Using low-quality paint or skipping proper surface prep leads to rapid paint failure, wasted effort, and potential material damage.

Invest in durable, high-quality paint suitable for historic substrates.
Clean all surfaces thoroughly—remove dirt, mildew, oil, and flaking paint.
Prime as needed to ensure good paint adhesion and longevity.

3. Applying Exterior Waterproof Coatings

Many products claim to “seal” or waterproof older homes, but these coat the building in a vapor barrier. Historic materials like brick, stone, and wood are designed to “breathe”—trapping moisture inside can cause blistered paint, crumbling plaster, and rot.

Keep water out by maintaining roofs, gutters, and downspouts, not by sealing walls with modern waterproofers.
Avoid vapor-barrier coatings on walls; opt for breathable finishes where necessary.

4. Using Abrasive Cleaning Techniques

Many older homeowners resort to sandblasting, power washing, or harsh chemical cleaners to remove years of grime. Unfortunately, these methods can erode delicate brick, stone, or wood and accelerate deterioration.

Choose gentle, non-abrasive cleaning techniques such as soft-bristle brushes, mild detergents, and low-pressure water.
Test cleaning methods on inconspicuous areas before widespread use.

5. Overlooking Outdated Electrical Systems

Original wiring in older houses may not meet today’s safety codes. Neglecting to upgrade old knob-and-tube or cloth-insulated wiring creates a fire hazard and can limit your home’s utility.

Have a qualified electrician inspect and update electrical systems early in your project.
Incorporate new wiring discreetly to respect historic character.

6. Cutting Corners on Plumbing

Old homes often contain corroded pipes, leaky joints, or outdated materials like lead or galvanized steel. Skipping plumbing upgrades can result in water damage, poor pressure, and health concerns.

Replace old supply lines and drains with safe, modern alternatives.
Check for hidden leaks and signs of corrosion behind walls and under floors.

7. Failing to Match Original Materials and Craftsmanship

Modern materials—vinyl windows, engineered trim, or cement-based mortars—may save time and money, but often clash with historic fabric in appearance and behavior. Using mismatched materials can harm aesthetics and reduce your home’s value.

Source period-appropriate materials whenever possible: original-style woodwork, lime mortar, and true divided-light windows.
Employ or consult with skilled craftspeople familiar with period details and techniques.

8. Applying Modern Portland Cement or Impermeable Mortar

Many restoration projects use modern mortar to repoint historic brick or stone, but traditional structures need lime-based, flexible, and permeable mortars. Portland cement is too hard, often cracks, and traps moisture.

Use a compatible lime-based mortar for repointing and repairs.
Research your building’s original construction for suitable materials.

9. Replacing Original Windows Unnecessarily

Historic wood windows made from old-growth timber can last for generations if maintained, whereas modern vinyl replacements lack character and often deteriorate faster.

Repair and restore existing windows whenever feasible.
Enhance energy efficiency with weatherstripping and well-fitted storms instead of replacing sashes.

10. Neglecting Proper Testing and Remediation for Hazards

Many period homes contain hazardous materials—notably lead paint and asbestos insulation. Ignoring testing or safe removal puts household health at risk.

Conduct professional hazard testing before disturbing painted surfaces or old insulation.
Hire certified remediation specialists for removal or encapsulation.

11. Installing Blown Insulation in Plaster Walls

While insulating attics and crawl spaces is beneficial, blowing cellulose or fiberglass into original plaster and lath wall cavities can trap moisture, leading to dampness and paint failure.

Keep wall cavities as originally designed to allow walls to “breathe.” Focus on attic and basement insulation for improved efficiency.

12. Neglecting Energy Efficiency and Comfort

Drafty windows, thin attic insulation, and outdated HVAC systems are common in old homes. Overlooking upgrades can result in discomfort and high utility bills.

Upgrade insulation in safe, non-invasive locations—attic, roof, and floors.
Consider energy-efficient, historically appropriate storm windows or secondary glazing.
Modernize heating and cooling systems while concealing ductwork and piping where possible.

13. Skipping Maintenance and Deferred Repairs

Putting off minor repairs—like fixing cracked mortar, patching leaks, or maintaining gutters—lets small issues escalate into major headaches.

Perform annual inspections of roof, foundation, windows, and drains.
Address issues promptly to preserve your home and avoid larger costs.

14. Using Pressure-Treated Wood for Repairs

Replacing deteriorated exterior wood with pressure-treated lumber can cause premature paint failure due to high moisture and chemical leaching. Over time, treated wood also warps and twists as it dries.

Choose rot-resistant woods like cypress, cedar, or Douglas fir for repairs.
Confirm that replacement wood is dry (<15% moisture) and suitable for painting.

15. Overlooking Hidden Costs and Planning Failures

Restoration projects almost always reveal unexpected surprises that swell timelines and budgets. Inadequate contingency plans can cause significant stress, unfinished projects, or cut corners.

Set aside a realistic contingency (typically 15–20%) for hidden repairs or code upgrades.
Seek expert advice and detailed inspections even for seemingly minor projects.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I update an old house without losing its historic charm?

A: Yes. With careful planning, sourcing period-appropriate materials, and consulting skilled tradespeople, you can modernize systems while retaining original details like woodwork, windows, and hardware.

Q: Is restoring old wood windows really worth it?

A: Absolutely. Original wood windows are usually made of superior materials and contribute to your home’s value and appearance. Restoration plus storm windows offers lasting results and excellent energy performance when done correctly.

Q: How do I test for lead and asbestos in my home?

A: Hire certified inspectors for professional testing. DIY tests may miss hidden sources or trigger unsafe exposure. Always follow local safety and remediation guidelines.

Q: What’s the biggest mistake people make when restoring old houses?

A: Failing to address root causes—whether structural damage, moisture intrusion, or hidden hazards—and making hasty cosmetic fixes that quickly fail or cause further harm is the most common and costly mistake.

Quick Reference Table: Common Mistakes & Better Approaches

Mistake	Consequences	Better Approach
Using waterproof exterior coatings	Trapped moisture, paint & plaster failure	Maintain drainage and use breathable paints
Replacing wood windows with vinyl	Loss of character, poor lifespan	Repair wood windows, add storms
Installing blown wall insulation	Dampness, mold, paint failure	Insulate attic & basement instead
Using mismatched modern materials	Incompatibility, visible mismatch	Source period-appropriate materials
Ignoring outdated electrical/plumbing	Safety hazards, leaks, inefficiency	Upgrade systems early in the restoration

Conclusion

Historic home restoration is both art and science. Avoiding these 15 common mistakes helps ensure your lovingly restored home stands the test of time—retaining its unique character while offering modern safety, comfort, and efficiency. Diligent planning, a respect for historic materials, and expert guidance are your best allies for a successful, stress-free project.

References

Author

medha deb

Medha Deb is an editor with a master's degree in Applied Linguistics from the University of Hyderabad. She believes that her qualification has helped her develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts.

Read full bio of medha deb