Elliptical vs. Treadmill: Which Cardio Machine Is Right For You?

Choosing the right cardio equipment can make a big impact on your fitness journey. Two of the most popular options in gyms and homes are the elliptical and the treadmill—each offering distinctive benefits for cardiovascular health, weight loss, and muscle toning. This guide will break down the differences between ellipticals and treadmills, compare their advantages and drawbacks, and help you decide which fits your exercise goals and lifestyle.

Understanding the Elliptical and Treadmill

Before diving into the details, it’s important to know what each machine does and how they generally work:

• Elliptical: Features two pedals and handlebars, allowing for a gliding, circular motion that can be performed forward or backward. The handlebars move in sync with your legs, engaging both upper and lower body muscles. Ellipticals are designed for low-impact cardio workouts.
• Treadmill: Has a rotating belt that permits walking, jogging, or running in place. Most models allow you to adjust speed and incline, customizing the level of intensity and mimicking outdoor activities. The treadmill is a high- or low-impact option depending on your pace.

Key Differences Between Elliptical and Treadmill Workouts

What Are the Benefits of Using an Elliptical?

• Low-Impact Cardio: The elliptical’s gliding motion places minimal stress on knees, hips, and ankles. It’s perfect for those with arthritis, joint pain, or anyone looking to reduce wear and tear on their body.
• Full-Body Workout: The moving handlebars activate not just your lower body, but also your upper body—including your arms, chest, shoulders, and core. This total-body engagement can maximize calorie burn and muscular endurance.
• Gentle Re-Entry After Injury: For individuals recovering from injuries or managing chronic conditions, ellipticals provide a safe and effective way to maintain fitness.
• Adjustable Resistance: You can easily modify resistance to make workouts harder, simulating hill climbing or strengthening different muscle groups (including by pedaling in reverse).
• Calorie Burning: Despite the lower joint impact, the elliptical can burn a significant number of calories, especially with increased resistance or speed. A 30-minute session may burn between 270–378 calories for most users, depending on weight and effort.

The Pros of Ellipticals

• Protects Joints: Suitable for beginners, older adults, and people with joint issues.
• Works More Muscles Overall: Especially effective for engaging biceps, triceps, and back muscles.
• Versatile Workout Options: Pedal backward, add intervals, or use only upper or lower body for targeted training.

The Drawbacks of Ellipticals

• Less Natural for Runners: The movement pattern isn’t identical to walking or running, which can limit sport-specific benefits.
• Lower Bone-Building Potential: Since your feet stay on the pedals, ellipticals offer less bone-strengthening impact than treadmills.
• May Not Challenge Advanced Athletes: Some high-level runners or competitors may outgrow even the toughest elliptical settings.

The Benefits of Using a Treadmill

• Versatile Intensity: From gentle walking to full-out sprinting, treadmills let you adjust speed and incline to fit your goals—whether it’s fat loss, fitness, or training for a race.
• Realistic Running & Walking: The mechanics closely mimic outdoor locomotion, making treadmills a top choice for aspiring runners and athletes.
• Bone-Strengthening Effects: The impact of foot strikes on the treadmill surface may help maintain or increase bone density, benefiting overall skeletal health.
• High Calorie Burn Potential: Running and incline walking can burn as many (or more) calories than elliptical training. A 30-minute run at a moderate pace could easily burn more than 350 calories or more, depending on your body size and workout intensity.
• Variety of Workouts: Easily incorporate intervals, hills, sprints, tempo runs, and walking sessions for continually fresh challenges.

The Pros of Treadmills

• Best for Runners: Allows realistic race training with pace and interval options.
• Increased Lower Body Strength: Especially effective for training glutes, calves, hamstrings, and quads.
• Customizable Intensity: Adjust incline, pace, and duration to suit any fitness level.

The Drawbacks of Treadmills

• Higher Joint Impact: Running, even on cushioned belts, is harder on knees, hips, and lower back—challenging for those prone to pain or injury.
• Limited Upper Body Engagement: Compared to the elliptical, treadmills generally do not provide significant arm or upper body work, unless used with light hand weights.
• Risk of Overuse Injuries: Repetitive pounding and improper form can increase the likelihood of stress fractures or sprains.

Which Burns More Calories: Elliptical or Treadmill?

Calorie burn depends on several factors: body weight, workout intensity, duration, resistance, and incline.

• Ellipticals often show a higher calorie burn for beginners and those less experienced.
• Treadmills generally match or surpass elliptical calorie burn at higher running speeds or on a steep incline.

The key is that both machines can help with weight loss and can be tailored to create effective, calorie-burning routines. The one you enjoy and will use consistently is likely to yield the greatest overall fat loss benefit.

Impact on Joints and Injury Concerns

The impact level of your workout is a major consideration, especially if you have a history of injury, joint pain, or chronic health conditions.

• Elliptical: The smooth, gliding stride means no jarring impact on ankles, knees, or hips. Suitable for individuals with arthritis, post-injury recovery, or those seeking a safer cardio choice as they age.
• Treadmill: Involves repeated foot strikes that are higher-impact, particularly at running speeds. Walking is gentler but may still aggravate conditions in sensitive individuals.

Consulting a physician or physical therapist is wise if you’re new to exercise or have existing injuries.

Muscle Groups Targeted: Elliptical vs. Treadmill

• Elliptical: Works glutes, quadriceps, hamstrings, calves, hip flexors, core, and—thanks to moving handlebars—biceps, triceps, shoulders, chest, and upper back (rhomboids).
• Treadmill: Focuses primarily on lower body (glutes, quads, hamstrings, calves, hip flexors, and core with proper form). Arm movement is voluntary and non-resistive.

Which Is Right for You?

Your fitness goals, joint health, and personal exercise preferences will determine which machine fits best. Consider the following:

• Choose an elliptical if you:
  • Need a low-impact, joint-friendly workout
  • Prefer full-body engagement
  • Are getting back into exercise after injury
  • Want a beginner-friendly machine
• Choose a treadmill if you:
  • Are training for a race or want to improve running mechanics
  • Love workout variety (walk, run, sprint, intervals, incline)
  • Seek targeted lower-body strengthening
  • Enjoy structured training plans

Ideally, alternating between both machines can prevent boredom, reduce overuse injuries, and provide a more comprehensive workout program, keeping your body challenged from multiple directions.

Sample Workouts for Weight Loss & Fitness

Elliptical Weight Loss Workout (30 Minutes Example)

• 5 minutes: Warm up at low resistance
• 20 minutes: Alternate 2 minutes at high resistance with 2 minutes at moderate resistance
• 5 minutes: Cool down at low resistance, stretching afterward
• Variation: Pedal backward every 5 minutes to target different muscle groups

Treadmill Weight Loss Workout (30 Minutes Example)

• 5 minutes: Warm-up walk at 0% incline
• 20 minutes: Alternate 1 minute running (or power walking) at 5-7% incline with 1–2 minutes walking at 2% incline
• 5 minutes: Cool down, gentle walk at 0% incline, followed by stretching
• Variation: Add short sprints or sessions at maximum incline for an added challenge

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are ellipticals better than treadmills for beginners?

Ellipticals are often recommended for beginners due to their smooth, low-impact motion that’s gentle on joints and easy to learn. They provide a full-body workout without the discomfort that running can cause for new exercisers.

Which burns more calories: ellipticals or treadmills?

Both machines can burn significant calories when used at high intensity. Ellipticals may show slightly higher calorie burn for beginners, but treadmills can equal or exceed that with running or incline work.

Are treadmills harder on your joints than ellipticals?

Yes. Treadmills—especially at running speeds—create higher impact, which can strain knees, ankles, and hips compared to the smooth gliding motion of ellipticals.

Is an elliptical good for weight loss compared to a treadmill?

Yes. Both machines are effective tools for weight loss if you work at a challenging pace and pair your routine with healthy nutrition. Higher resistance or incline on either machine can boost calorie expenditure.

Which is better for race training: elliptical or treadmill?

A treadmill is more appropriate for race preparation, as it mimics real running mechanics and allows you to set and practice specific paces, intervals, and inclines.

Can ellipticals build more muscle than treadmills?

Ellipticals engage both upper and lower body muscles due to the moving handles, making them more effective for total-body conditioning. Treadmills focus mainly on lower body muscles.

Should I use both machines?

Using both is ideal for maximizing variety, reducing injury risk, and keeping your regimen exciting. Many fitness trainers recommend a mix for balanced results.

Which treadmill workout is best for weight loss?

Interval training (alternating bursts of high-intensity effort with recovery periods) and incline walking are among the most effective treadmill routines for calorie burn and fat loss.

Conclusion

Both ellipticals and treadmills are valuable tools for achieving cardiovascular fitness, burning calories, and enhancing your overall health. Your individual goals, health concerns, and exercise preferences should guide your choice. Whichever machine you choose, consistency and enjoyment are the keys to success.

Similar Articles

Screen Time & Frustration: How Passive Viewing Impacts Children’s Emotional Regulation

Screen-Free Activities for High Sensory Seeking Kids: Engaging Minds and Bodies Without Electronics

Cleaning Kids’ Device Screens: Hygiene & Longevity Tips for Safe, Effective Care

Smart Plugs to Enforce Wi-Fi Shutdown Routine: Comprehensive Guide, Benefits, and Best Practices

Screen-Free Family Night Routine Implementation Plan: A Comprehensive Guide for Healthier Bonds

The Best Alternatives to Yoto Player and Tonies for Screen-Free Audio Entertainment (2025 Guide)

Author

medha deb

 

Medha Deb is an editor with a master's degree in Applied Linguistics from the University of Hyderabad. She believes that her qualification has helped her develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts.

Read full bio of medha deb