Hemodialysis vs. Peritoneal Dialysis: Understanding Your Options
A comprehensive guide to hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis, comparing procedures, benefits, risks, and how to choose the right treatment.
For people living with chronic kidney disease (CKD) or end-stage renal disease (ESRD), dialysis becomes essential when the kidneys can no longer filter waste and excess fluid adequately. Two main types of dialysis—hemodialysis (HD) and peritoneal dialysis (PD)—offer life-extending treatment options, yet each works differently, comes with unique benefits and risks, and fits different lifestyles. This guide will help you understand how each method works, their pros and cons, and how to approach choosing the right option with your healthcare team.
Key Differences Between Hemodialysis and Peritoneal Dialysis
| Hemodialysis | Peritoneal Dialysis | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | A machine filters your blood outside the body using a dialyzer (artificial kidney). | Your abdominal lining (peritoneum) acts as a natural filter; dialysis fluid absorbs waste through this membrane inside your body. |
| Access Point | AV fistula, AV graft, or central venous catheter—typically in your arm | A soft catheter surgically placed into your abdomen |
| Location | Primarily dialysis centers; home options exist | Primarily performed at home; rare in clinics |
| Frequency & Duration |
|
|
| Common Side Effects & Risks |
|
|
| Dietary Guidelines |
| Similar to hemodialysis, but dietary and fluid restrictions may be less severe |
| Cost | Typically more expensive | Usually less costly |
What is Hemodialysis?
Hemodialysis is a type of dialysis therapy that uses a machine called a dialyzer, sometimes referred to as an artificial kidney, to filter toxins, excess salts, and fluid from the blood. Hemodialysis replaces several of the filtering functions of the kidney and is the most commonly used form of dialysis worldwide.
How Does Hemodialysis Work?
Hemodialysis requires vascular access—commonly an arteriovenous (AV) fistula, AV graft, or sometimes a central venous catheter—to remove blood from your body for cleaning. The blood passes through the dialyzer, which uses a semi-permeable membrane and a special cleansing solution (dialysate) to remove waste, and is returned to the body.
- Setting: Most patients receive hemodialysis at a specialized center, though home hemodialysis is an option for a select group.
- Treatment frequency: Generally, sessions are scheduled three times per week, with each session lasting three to five hours, depending on your clinical needs.
- Monitoring: Healthcare professionals monitor your vital signs and fluid status during treatments.
Benefits of Hemodialysis
- Frequent contact with medical professionals for ongoing care
- Often preferred for patients with advanced or unstable kidney failure
- Treatments in staffed clinics for extra safety oversight
- Potentially better for individuals who may not manage dialysis independently
Potential Drawbacks and Risks of Hemodialysis
- Restricted diet and fluid intake
- Vascular access can become infected or clotted
- Fatigue, low blood pressure, and muscle cramps are common
- Greater impact on scheduling and daily routines, especially for those in center-based care
- Some people experience ‘dialysis disequilibrium syndrome’—a sudden shift in fluid and electrolytes causing headaches, nausea, or confusion
What is Peritoneal Dialysis?
Peritoneal dialysis offers a home-based alternative that uses your body’s own abdominal membrane as a filter. A special solution called dialysate is infused through a surgically placed catheter into your abdomen. Waste products and excess fluid move from your blood into the solution through the peritoneal membrane, and the used fluid is later drained away.
What others are reading
Types of Peritoneal Dialysis
- Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis (CAPD): Performed manually, 3–5 times a day, where the dialysate is allowed to dwell in the abdomen and then drained out and replaced with fresh solution.
- Automated Peritoneal Dialysis (APD): Uses a computerized machine (cycler) to perform multiple fluid exchanges automatically, usually overnight while the patient sleeps.
Benefits of Peritoneal Dialysis
- Greater flexibility and independence—can be performed at home, work, or while traveling
- Smoother, more continuous filtration that may reduce symptoms like fatigue
- Fewer restrictions on diet and fluids for many patients
- Needles not required once catheter is in place
- Better blood pressure control
Potential Drawbacks and Risks of Peritoneal Dialysis
- Risk of peritonitis—a serious abdominal infection
- Need for strict sterile technique during exchanges to prevent infection
- Possible weight gain and higher blood sugar from glucose in dialysate
- Not suitable for patients with extensive abdominal scarring, obesity, or certain medical conditions
- Hernia risk increases because of elevated intra-abdominal pressure
Comparing Clinical Effectiveness and Outcomes
Both hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis are effective at replacing lost kidney function and improving the quality of life for people with advanced kidney disease. Recent research findings include:
- Both methods lower blood urea nitrogen (BUN), a major marker of kidney function. PD may provide better stability in blood pressure and waste clearance for some people.
- Albumin (a blood protein) often increases more after hemodialysis, while cardiac ejection fraction—a measure of heart function—may improve more in PD.
- Rates of complications, such as hypo/hypertension, vary, but PD is associated with fewer total complications in some studies.
- There’s no significant difference in overall survival between methods, according to long-term analyses. However, older age and infections impact outcomes in both groups.
Which Method Is Better?
No single treatment is universally “better.” Your choice should account for medical needs, lifestyle, personal preferences, and access to support. Some factors influencing decision include:
- Medical contraindications (prior abdominal surgery, severe obesity may discourage PD)
- Ability to perform home care tasks for PD
- Distance from dialysis centers and local medical resources
- Other co-existing health conditions
- Preferences for privacy, flexibility, or structured care
Dietary Considerations and Lifestyle Impacts
Both forms of dialysis require diet and fluid adjustments to help control symptoms and prevent complications. Typical recommendations include:
- Sodium, potassium, and phosphorus: Restrict intake to prevent fluid overload and electrolyte disturbances
- Protein: Intake is usually increased, especially for people on hemodialysis
- Fluid: Strict daily limits for those on hemodialysis; PD patients often have fewer restrictions due to continuous filtration
- Calories and sugar: Monitor closely, especially in PD, where glucose-rich dialysate can contribute to weight gain or high blood sugar
Weighing the Financial Costs
- Hemodialysis: Typically involves higher costs due to frequent clinical visits, machine use, and intensive staff involvement.
- Peritoneal dialysis: Generally less expensive, as most treatments occur at home and do not require expensive machinery or regular in-clinic sessions.
However, insurance coverage, government programs, location, and supplies can greatly affect out-of-pocket expenses. Consult your healthcare provider and insurance for detailed cost assessments.
Making the Choice: Factors to Consider
- Your overall health and individual medical conditions
- Your ability (and/or caregiver’s ability) to manage treatments at home
- Support network—family, friends, or trained aides
- Preferences for flexibility (PD) versus structure (HD)
- Tolerance and previous experiences with needles, catheters, or infections
- Accessibility to dialysis centers or healthcare providers
- Cost and insurance coverage for both types
Meeting with your nephrologist, dialysis nurse, social worker, and dietitian can help you weigh these factors to make a shared and informed decision.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Which dialysis method is more common?
A: Hemodialysis is more common in many countries, partly due to healthcare infrastructure and clinician familiarity. However, peritoneal dialysis is being increasingly promoted as a home-based option in several regions.
Q: Can I travel if I am on dialysis?
A: Travel is possible with both types of dialysis. Peritoneal dialysis allows for more flexibility, letting patients perform exchanges almost anywhere. For hemodialysis, arrangements can be made for sessions at other clinics ahead of time.
Q: Are there restrictions on activities while on dialysis?
A: Most people resume many daily activities. Similarly, with PD, attention to hygiene during exchanges is essential, and heavy lifting may be limited. Hemodialysis patients may feel fatigued after treatment but can generally stay active between sessions.
Q: What is the biggest risk with peritoneal dialysis?
A: The most serious risk is peritonitis—a potentially life-threatening abdominal infection. Careful training and good technique can minimize this risk. Other risks include hernia and catheter-related infections.
Q: Is home dialysis safe?
A: Home dialysis (both HD and PD) is safe for many people who receive proper training, have a suitable environment, and ongoing support. Regular monitoring is still required.
More Resources & Support
- National Kidney Foundation
- American Association of Kidney Patients
- National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases
- Consult your nephrologist or dialysis team for personalized recommendations
Choosing a dialysis method is a personal decision reliant on your unique health, preferences, and circumstances. Involvement of your medical team, support network, and careful research can help you make the best decision for your well-being.
References
- https://www.healthline.com/health/kidney-disease/hemodialysis-vs-peritoneal-dialysis
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10626077/
- https://lincolnwoodhc.com/hemodialysis-vs-peritoneal-dialysis/
- https://www.durhamnephrology.com/hemodialysis-vs-peritoneal-dialysis/
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10139729/
- https://www.kidney.org/kidney-topics/choosing-dialysis-which-type-right-me
- https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/peritoneal-dialysis/about/pac-20384725
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
