Avoid These Plants: What Not to Grow With Tomatoes
Protect your vegetable patch from hidden conflicts and enjoy healthier, abundant fruits.
Plants to Avoid with Tomatoes: Essential Companion Planting Advice
Tomatoes are prized for their delicious fruits and versatility in the kitchen, making them a staple in vegetable gardens worldwide. However, tomatoes donât thrive alongside every plant. In fact, poor companion choices can lead to reduced yields, increased disease, and overall plant stress. Understanding which plants to avoidâwith a focus on science-backed reasonsâcan make the difference between a flourishing tomato patch and a struggling one.
Why Companion Planting Matters for Tomatoes
Companion planting, or intercropping, is the practice of growing different crops in proximity for mutual benefit. Tomatoes benefit from this method when surrounded by plants that deter pests, attract pollinators, or create beneficial microclimates. However, when tomatoes are planted too close to certain incompatible crops, the competition or biochemical interactions can be detrimental.
- Pest management: Some plant families share common pests or diseases, increasing risks.
- Resource competition: Heavy feeders can outcompete tomatoes for nutrients and water.
- Allelopathy: Certain plants release chemicals that inhibit tomato growth or kill seedlings.
- Microclimate impacts: Tall or dense plants may shade tomatoes, reducing sunlight exposure.
What Plants Should Be Kept Away from Tomatoes?
Here are the most important plants to avoid growing near your tomatoes, along with details on why they’re problematic:
1. Potatoes (Solanum tuberosum)
Potatoes and tomatoes belong to the same plant familyâthe nightshades or Solanaceae.
- Shared Pests & Diseases: Both can be attacked by late blight, early blight, and other soilborne pathogens, which can rapidly spread between the two crops.
- Competition: Root systems compete for soil nutrients and water.
If you must grow both, rotate locations yearly and keep beds separate to minimize risk.
2. Corn (Zea mays)
- Shading: Corn grows tall and can overshadow tomato plants, limiting tomato access to essential sunlight.
- Pest Magnet: Both are susceptible to the tomato fruitworm/corn earworm, which can devastate both crops if planted in proximity.
For best results, avoid planting corn within the same plot or right next to tomato beds.
3. Fennel (Foeniculum vulgare)
- Allelopathic Effects: Fennel exudes chemicals from its roots that inhibit growth of many plants, including tomatoes.
- Growth Stagnation: Tomatoes may struggle to grow or show signs of stunted development near fennel.
Plant fennel at the margins of the garden, using isolated containers or a separate raised bed for best results.
4. Brassicas (Broccoli, Cabbage, Cauliflower, Kale, Brussels Sprouts)
- Heavy Feeders: Brassicas require substantial soil nutrients, directly competing with tomatoes for food and water.
- Potential Stunting: Crowded conditions, especially with inadequate soil fertility, can stunt both crop groups.
What others are reading
Some gardeners report success with brassicas and tomatoes sharing wide, heavily mulched and fertilized beds, but separation is usually best.
5. Black Walnuts (Juglans nigra) and Juglone-Producing Trees
- Juglone Production: Black walnut trees exude juglone, a biochemical that stunts or kills tomatoes (and many other vegetables) within a root zone radius of 50 feet.
- Symptoms: Wilting, yellowing, failure to thrive, and even rapid plant death can be traced to juglone exposure.
Grow tomatoes in raised beds with fresh soil if black walnut trees are anywhere nearby, and vigilantly remove walnut leaves, hulls, and roots from beds.
6. Nightshade Cousins: Eggplant, Peppers (Solanum melongena, Capsicum species)
- Shared Diseases: Like potatoes, these relate to tomatoes botanically and share susceptibility to blight, wilt, and pest issues.
- Crop Rotation: Avoid planting these crops in the same location year after year to reduce pathogen build-up in the soil.
With careful attention to crop rotation and disease management, some gardeners can co-plant peppers and tomatoes, but risks are elevated.
7. Other Notable Incompatible Plants
- Dill (Mature Stage): Although young dill can benefit tomatoes, mature dill roots may inhibit growth much like fennel.
- Kohlrabi: Another Brassica family member considered a poor companion for tomatoes.
- Cabbage family again: All members are heavy feeders, which can cause similar issues as described above.
Why These Plants Cause Problems: The Science Behind Incompatibility
Each plant exerts influence over its neighbors in the garden via competition, pest attraction, allelopathic chemicals, or microclimate shifts. Hereâs how the science plays out:
- Competition: When plants need the same nutrients or moisture, one may outcompete the other, leaving the weaker plant stunted. Tomatoes, being heavy feeders themselves, often suffer when paired with nutrient-hungry crops like brassicas.
- Allelopathy: Substances like juglone (walnuts), and certain root exudates from fennel and mature dill, directly inhibit growth, seed germination, or nutrient uptake in tomato plants.
- Disease Transmission: Close relatives in the nightshade family (Solanaceae) share a host of fungal and bacterial threats; pathogens can persist in the soil and spread rapidly between related crops grown near one another or in subsequent seasons.
- Pest Reservoirs: Some plants serve as alternative hosts for tomato-damaging insects (such as hornworms, fruitworms, stink bugs, or aphids).
- Sunlight Issues: Tall crops (corn, sunflowers) can overshadow tomato plants, blocking sunlight essential for robust fruiting.
Best Practices for Planting Tomatoes
- Plant tomatoes far from potatoes, corn, and brassicas (ideally in separate beds if space allows).
- If you have walnut trees, always situate tomatoes at least 50 feet away, or use isolated raised beds filled with uncontaminated soil.
- Avoid planting tomatoes repeatedly in the same spot each year, especially near other Solanaceae crops, to break disease and pest cycles.
- Monitor fennel, dill, and their mature stagesâgrow in separate containers whenever possible to prevent allelopathic problems.
What Can You Grow With Tomatoes? (Companion Suggestions)
Beneath the question âWhat shouldnât you grow with tomatoes?â lies an equally important answer: What makes a good tomato companion? Popular tomato-friendly plants include:
- Basil: Repels thrips and makes for tastier tomatoes.
- Marigolds: Deter nematodes and other pests with their root secretions.
- Lettuce and carrots: Use different levels of soil nutrients and minimize competition.
- Garlic and onions: Their pungent scent may ward off insect pests.
Always tailor companion planting to your siteâs unique light, soil, and space constraints.
Table: Problematic Plants for Tomatoes and Why
| Plant | Main Problem | Recommended Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Potatoes | Shared pests (blight), competition | Different beds/rotate annually |
| Corn | Shade, shared pest (fruitworm) | Do not interplant or adjacent rows |
| Fennel | Allelopathic chemicals | Separate bed or container |
| Brassicas (Cabbage, etc.) | Nutrient competition | Separate beds |
| Black Walnut (Juglone zone) | Juglone toxicity | 50+ feet, or raised beds |
| Eggplant, Peppers | Shared diseases | Rotate, monitor for pests |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Can I plant tomatoes and cucumbers together?
A: Yes! Cucumbers and tomatoes have different disease profiles and grow well together, provided they each have room to climb or sprawl.
Q: Why are my tomatoes turning yellow and wilting near my walnut tree?
A: This is likely due to juglone toxicity. Black walnuts inhibit tomato growth through a root chemical. Move tomato beds as far as possible from the tree or use isolated raised beds.
Q: Is it okay to grow peppers with tomatoes?
A: While possible, it is risky: both are nightshades and susceptible to similar pests and diseases. Rotate plantings annually to minimize long-term issues.
Q: Will planting basil improve my tomato harvest?
A: Basil is a classic tomato companion, enhancing flavor, deterring some pests, and acting as a groundcover. Plant together for best results.
Q: How can I prevent plant diseases if I have limited space?
A: Practice crop rotation, ensure good air circulation, fertilize adequately, and use mulch to prevent soil splash and reduce pathogen spread. Remove lower tomato leaves as they age to further limit disease risk.
Key Takeaways for Successful Tomato Companion Planting
- Know your plant familiesâavoid most nightshades, brassicas, and juglone producers near tomatoes.
- Maximize plant diversity for resilience, but avoid well-known antagonists.
- Use good garden hygiene practicesâcrop rotation, mulching, and raised beds can mitigate many problems.
- Monitor and address conflicting growth trends early in the season for the best harvest.
By following these simple but science-backed principles, you can set the stage for productive, healthy tomato plants and bountiful harvests year after year.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Srija Burman
