The Ultimate Chocolate Ice Cream Taste Test: Supermarket Brands Ranked
Discover which grocery freezer aisle choices deliver true indulgence in every spoonful.
Few desserts evoke as much devotion as chocolate ice cream. In home freezers and parlor cases alike, it remains an American classic, spawning heated debates about which store brand reigns supreme. To uncover the true champion, a rigorous side-by-side blind taste test was conducted on a wide selection of supermarket chocolate ice creams, focusing on both beloved classics and premium indulgences. This article rigorously examines the brands, flavor profiles, and textures that set the best chocolate ice creams apart.
Why Chocolate Ice Cream Matters
In the world of frozen desserts, chocolate ice cream stands second only to vanilla in popularity, yet it is arguably a bolder, more divisive choice. Unlike vanilla, where minor differences may be subtle, chocolate ice cream varies dramatically in cocoa richness, sugar content, and dairy creaminess. Even among major supermarket brands, the difference between satisfying nostalgia and a disappointing scoop is substantial.
- Cocoa Intensity – Ranges from mellow milk-chocolate flavors to nearly bitter, dark-chocolate profiles.
- Creaminess – Some brands deliver a silky, custard-like mouthfeel, while others settle for icier, lighter textures.
- Sugar Balance – A successful chocolate ice cream must balance sweetness with chocolate’s natural bitterness.
- Melt-ability – Creamy, smooth melting on the tongue is a marker of premium ingredients and careful churning.
- Aftertaste – The best leave a lingering cocoa note, not a waxy or artificial finish.
The Methodology: Rigorous Blind Tasting
A diverse panel of tasters assembled, including a food writer, culinary enthusiasts, and home cooks. Ice creams were blindly tasted to reduce bias, with each participant recording their impressions based solely on taste, texture, and enjoyment. Each brand received a numeric score for:
- Overall Flavor
- Creaminess / Texture
- Melt Quality
- Appearance and Smell (as tiebreakers)
Where ties occurred, panelists re-tasted contenders side by side, prioritizing flavor, then creaminess, then melt-quality. Prices were noted, but value did not override the search for the best-tasting ice cream.
Brands Evaluated
The following brands, commonly found in US supermarkets, formed the core of this taste test:
- Ben & Jerry’s
- Häagen-Dazs
- Tillamook
- Turkey Hill
- Breyer’s
- Friendly’s
- 365 by Whole Foods Market
- Kroger Deluxe
- Publix Premium
- Signature Select (Albertsons/Safeway store brand)
- Private Selection
- Blue Bell
- Jeni’s
- Edy’s / Dreyer’s
Note: Availability may vary by region; some regional variations were substituted where necessary.
Overall Rankings: The Chocolate Ice Cream Scoreboard
Below, supermarket chocolate ice creams are ranked from lowest scoring to best, with notes on each brand’s flavor and texture.
| Rank | Brand | Main Notes | Average Score (Out of 5) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | Tillamook (Neapolitan) | Disappointing chocolate flavor, bland and overshadowed by strawberry/vanilla; lacks richness. | 2.2 |
| 13 | Kroger Deluxe | Mild flavor; texture passable but uninspiring; good for budget-buyers. | 3.2 |
| 12 | 365 by Whole Foods Market | Overly sweet, artificial finish; texture on the icy side. | 3.3 |
| 11 | Friendly’s | Milky and light, but lacks true chocolate punch; decent melt. | 3.4 |
| 10 | Edy’s / Dreyer’s | Balanced but utterly forgettable; middle-of-the-road in every respect. | 3.5 |
| 9 | Signature Select | Richness attempts fall flat; texture gooey rather than creamy. | 3.5 |
| 8 | Blue Bell | Light, classic but simple; leans nostalgic. | 3.6 |
| 7 | Turkey Hill | Milky, approachable, some depth but short on premium appeal. | 3.7 |
| 6 | Publix Premium | Surprisingly satisfying classic flavor; not decadent but enjoyable. Texture shines. | 3.8 |
| 5 | Private Selection | Delicate cocoa, dense and rich mouthfeel, above-average finish. | 4.0 |
| 4 | Breyer’s | Light yet intense real chocolate; less creamy than others but delivers on flavor. | 4.0 |
| 3 | Jeni’s | Artisan decadence: high cocoa, fudge-like, complex, best for serious chocolate fans. | 4.1 |
| 2 | Ben & Jerry’s | Rich, deep cocoa with trademark chewiness; mix-ins popular but chocolate base holds up solo. | 4.2 |
| 1 | Häagen-Dazs | Ultra-creamy, intense cocoa, balanced sweet/salty finish; tastes premium from the first bite. | 4.3 |
In-Depth Tasting Notes & Highlights
Tillamook
Tillamook’s Neapolitan was included because its chocolate stripe serves as flagship chocolate in some regions. For chocolate lovers, though, it’s a letdown. The chocolate component is bland and quickly overtaken by the other flavors. Despite Tillamook’s cheese dominance, its basic chocolate ice cream needs more depth.
What others are reading
Kroger Deluxe
Kroger’s chocolate ice cream is straightforward and affordable. It’s not bad, but it’s unspectacular—with a flavor profile that leans more to the sweet and milky than chocolaty and rich. Texture is smooth, but overall, this is for buyers seeking value over flavor fireworks.
365 by Whole Foods Market
Despite sourcing organic ingredients, 365’s chocolate ice cream doesn’t wow. Reviewers noted a noticeable artificial sweetness with an icy undertone. Chocolate presence is muted, landing it in the lower half of the rankings.
Friendly’s
A mainstay of the East Coast, Friendly’s brings a milky, old-fashioned character to chocolate ice cream. Some tasters liked the gentle flavor, but the consensus was that it doesn’t deliver enough chocolate punch.
Edy’s / Dreyer’s
Edy’s (or Dreyer’s, depending on your location) occupies the neutral middle ground. It’s creamy, not too sweet, but also not very memorable. For school parties or sundaes, it’s an easy crowd-pleaser, but serious chocoholics may crave more intensity.
Signature Select
As a Safeway/Albertsons store brand, Signature Select aims for richness but ends up with a chewy texture and slightly cloying finish. It’s an improvement over cheaper brands, but doesn’t crack the upper tier.
Blue Bell
Blue Bell offers a light, classic version of chocolate ice cream reminiscent of mid-century soda-shop treats. The flavor is nostalgic, though it lacks the depth of darker, modern chocolates.
Turkey Hill
Turkey Hill is milky and easy-going with just enough cocoa to feel legit. Devotees praise its balance, but its restraint may disappoint those hunting for maximum chocolate flavor.
Publix Premium
Publix Premium earns above-average scores for delivering a strong, classic chocolate taste along with a creamy texture that rivals pricier options. Even picky tasters found it “surprisingly satisfying.”
Private Selection
Kroger’s upscale line, Private Selection impresses with a more decadent mouthfeel and a cocoa-forward profile that’s both delicate and nuanced. Fares well in flavor and finish, even if not quite artisan-tier.
Breyers
Breyers splits opinions: some love the light, clean, true-chocolate taste, while others wish for added creaminess. Nonetheless, its use of real cocoa ingredients lets the chocolate speak. For purists seeking a lighter scoop, Breyer’s is a standout.
Jeni’s
Jeni’s is the artisan outlier—dark, complex, nearly reminiscent of frozen ganache. It’s dense, bold, and almost fudge-like. The only knock? It may be too intense, and too expensive, for some everyday eaters.
Ben & Jerry’s
Renowned for creative mix-ins, Ben & Jerry’s chocolate base stands up strong even without chunks or swirls. Deep, rich, and almost chewy, it satisfies chocolate cravings with every bite. True fans celebrate its balance of sweetness and cocoa power.
Häagen-Dazs
The clear winner: Häagen-Dazs delivers on every front. Tasters praised its ultra-smooth texture, profound cocoa depth, and the luxurious creaminess that lingers. The chocolate is pronounced without being overpowering; sweet, but perfectly in check. For those who want to experience the very best supermarket chocolate ice cream, this was the benchmark scoop.
What Makes Chocolate Ice Cream Truly Great?
Dissecting the winners, a few critical elements consistently separated the great from the good or merely acceptable:
- High Cocoa Content – Higher-quality ice creams boast a greater proportion of cocoa or chocolate liquor, boosting depth and authenticity.
- Real Dairy Fat – More cream and less filler results in smoother, more satisfying texture.
- Minimal Additives – Top-tier brands have fewer stabilizers or gums, relying on proper formulation instead of shortcuts.
- Measured Sweetness – The best balance the sugar so it enhances, not overpowers, the chocolate.
Lower-scoring brands often fell into predictable traps, such as using too much corn syrup, artificial flavoring, or simply skimping on cream.
Tips for Buying the Best Chocolate Ice Cream
- Scan the ingredients for real cream, cocoa or chocolate liquor, and minimal additives.
- Look for low air (overrun); premium ice creams feel dense, not fluffy.
- Purchase from stores with fast product turnover to ensure freshness.
- If possible, let your ice cream rest at room temperature for a few minutes before scooping – flavors bloom as the temperature rises slightly.
FAQs: Chocolate Ice Cream Shopping and Enjoyment
What determines the difference between premium and regular chocolate ice cream?
Premium ice creams usually have higher butterfat (cream) content, lower overrun (less air whipped in), and a greater proportion of real cocoa or chocolate liquor. This results in a creamier, denser product with more pronounced chocolate flavor.
Why do some chocolate ice creams taste icy rather than creamy?
An “icy” texture often indicates high water content, excessive air (overrun), or insufficient dairy fat. Lower-cost brands may also use more stabilizers, leading to a less smooth melt.
Is “Dutch process” chocolate in ice cream better?
Dutch-processed cocoa has been alkalized for a smoother, less acidic flavor and deeper brown color. Many premium brands use it for a richer and more mellow profile, though preferences vary.
Are store brand ice creams always inferior to name brands?
While some store brands disappoint, others, especially “private label” or “premium” lines (such as Private Selection or Publix Premium), can rival national brands on both flavor and value.
How should chocolate ice cream be stored for best texture?
Keep ice cream stored at the coldest part of your freezer, tightly covered. To avoid iciness, press a piece of waxed paper or plastic directly onto the surface before replacing the lid if you don’t plan to finish the carton quickly.
Conclusion
Chocolate ice cream remains a deeply personal pleasure—yet this rigorous taste test highlights which supermarket options deliver not just comfort but true cocoa excellence. Whether you love a classic, creamy scoop or a dark, decadent fudge bomb, there’s a top-ranked option waiting in your grocer’s freezer. For the best experience, seek out Häagen-Dazs or Ben & Jerry’s for indulgence, while value-hunters might be surprised by strong showings from Breyers, Private Selection, and Publix Premium. Above all else, let your own palate be the final judge—but use this guide to maximize your satisfaction on every spoonful.
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
