How to Make Spicy Spring-Style Sicilian Pizza at Home
Unlock restaurant-quality crunch and a fiery flavor boost with every homemade slice.
Spicy Spring Sicilian pizza has become an icon among New York City pies. With its thick, airy, olive oil-enriched crust, tangy tomato sauce, bubbling cheese, and signature spicy pepperoni cups, it’s a pizza lover’s dream—a food that inspires cross-state pilgrimages to Prince Street Pizza. Thankfully, with attention to technique and quality ingredients, you can bake a savory, golden, and satisfyingly spicy Sicilian pizza in your own kitchen. This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know—from mastering the dough to handling the toppings and achieving an ultra-crisp bottom and irresistible flavor combination.
What Makes Spicy Spring Sicilian Pizza Special?
Not all Sicilian pies are created equal. Prince Street’s Spicy Spring pizza has garnered a cult following for several reasons:
- Thick, yet Airy Crust: The crust is substantial with a crisp edge and a light, open crumb inside, the result of long, cold fermentation and a high hydration dough.
- Square Pan Bake: Unlike Neapolitan or NY-style round pizzas, it’s baked in a well-oiled square or rectangular pan to develop a crunchy, almost fried bottom.
- Zesty Sauce: A vibrant, simple tomato sauce is ladled generously on top of the pizza, contributing spicy, tangy, and sweet notes.
- Cup-and-Char Pepperoni: Small-diameter, thick-cut, natural-casing pepperoni slices curl into spicy cups filled with rendered fat—a textural and flavor highlight.
- Cheese Layer: The cheese is a blend of low-moisture mozzarella and sharp provolone, which provides both meltability and sharpness.
Key Ingredients
Authenticity starts with quality ingredients. Here are the essentials:
- Flour: Use high-gluten or bread flour for structure and chew. All-purpose can work but won’t yield the same texture.
- Water: Hydration is high for Sicilian dough, resulting in an open crumb. Use filtered water if possible.
- Yeast: Instant or active dry yeast both work. Fresh yeast is less common but can be substituted by weight.
- Extra-Virgin Olive Oil: Adds flavor and helps crisp the crust during the bake.
- Tomatoes: Use quality canned whole San Marzano or other Italian plum tomatoes for the sauce.
- Cheese: Low-moisture mozzarella, with optional sharp provolone for flavor complexity.
- Pepperoni: Seek out natural-casing, small-diameter ‘cup-and-char’ style for authentic look and taste.
- Salt, Black Pepper, Oregano, and Red Pepper Flakes: For seasoning the sauce and finishing the pie.
Sicilian Pizza Dough: The Foundation
The dough is the soul of Sicilian pizza. A proper Spicy Spring crust should be lofty, crisp around the edges and bottom, and tender within.
Hydration and Mixing
- Hydration: Typically 70–75% water to flour by weight. This slack dough creates an airy, moist crumb.
- Mixing: Either by hand or stand mixer, mix ingredients until smooth and very sticky. A long resting period will assist gluten development.
Cold Fermentation
- Let the dough slow-rise in the refrigerator for 12 to 72 hours. This extended fermentation develops complex flavor and airy structure.
- Oil your pan generously, then stretch the chilled dough gently into pan. Rest at room temperature to allow for final proofing until doubled and puffy.
Tips for Great Sicilian Crust
- Use plenty of olive oil in pan—this is what gives the crust its fried, golden bottom and crisp edges.
- Don’t force the dough—it will shrink if you stretch it too aggressively. Let it relax and stretch in short intervals if necessary.
- Be patient during proofing; a properly risen dough delivers the best texture.
Zesty Tomato Sauce: The Signature Flavor Layer
Simple ingredients create a sauce that’s bright, fresh, and punchy:
- Crushed quality canned tomatoes (hand-crushed is best for texture)
- Olive oil, garlic, and onion
- Dried oregano
- Salt, black pepper, and crushed red pepper flakes for heat and sharpness
Simmer the sauce only briefly to preserve its vibrancy. A little rawness is intentional—it balances the rich, fatty toppings and dough.
Cheese and Topping Strategy
The cheese layer is crucial for melt and flavor:
- Low-moisture mozzarella is cubed or grated for even melt.
- Sharp provolone or pecorino adds tang; optional but recommended.
- Pepperoni: Look for small-diameter, natural-casing, thick sliced. ‘Cup-and-char’ is the hallmark— as it bakes, the edges curl into little bowls of spicy, crunchy, fatty goodness.
What others are reading
Spread cheese evenly across the dough after par-baking (optional, see below), followed by an abundant, even layer of pepperoni. Don’t be shy—this pie should be lavishly topped!
Assembly: Layering for Success
- Stretch the risen dough into a well-oiled square or quarter-sheet pan.
- Par-bake (optional): Bake dough briefly without toppings to set edges for an extra-crisp crust. This step is not essential but can make handling easier.
- Add cheese, then sauce: Sprinkle cheese directly over the crust first—this protects the base and prevents sogginess. Dollop sauce over cheese in a swirling or stripe pattern.
- Add pepperoni: Arrange slices edge-to-edge atop the sauce for maximum cup-and-char effect.
- Bake at high heat: 500°F (260°C) or as hot as your oven allows, for 18–22 minutes, until cheese bubbles and pepperoni cups.
- Cool and finish: Allow pizza to cool for a few minutes before serving—this sets the structure and enhances slicing. Finish with a drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of oregano if desired.
Expert Tips for Success
- If the dough resists stretching, let it rest covered for 10 minutes and try again.
- Use a kitchen scale for precise dough and sauce ingredients. Italian-style pizza rewards accuracy.
- For best crust, preheat your oven for at least 45 minutes with the pan placed on a bottom rack or even directly on a pizza stone or steel for max heat transfer.
- Don’t overload on sauce; too much can weigh down the crumb. It’s better to add a little less, then supplement after baking if needed.
- Slice with a sharp pizza cutter or heavy chef’s knife to preserve those crispy edges!
Sample Ingredient Table
| Ingredient | Quantity | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| High-gluten or bread flour | 500g (3 1/4 cups) | For chewy crumb structure |
| Water | 350-375g (1 1/2 cups) | High hydration for airiness |
| Yeast | 2g (1/2 tsp) | Instant or active dry |
| Kosher salt | 10g (2 tsp) | Flavor, gluten structure |
| Olive oil | 25g (2 tbsp) + more for pan | Enhances texture and browning |
| Canned tomatoes | 1 (28-oz) can | San Marzano or similar |
| Low-moisture mozzarella | 225g (8 oz) | Grated or cubed |
| Sharp provolone | Optional, 30g (1 oz) | For extra tang |
| ‘Cup-and-char’ pepperoni | 100-150g (3–5 oz) | Thick-sliced, natural casing |
| Seasonings | To taste | Oregano, black pepper, red pepper flakes |
Baking and Serving Suggestions
- Bake until the bottom is golden and the cheese is bubbling vigorously at the edges—don’t underbake.
- Let the pizza cool for 5–10 minutes before lifting from the pan—this keeps the crust crisp and easier to slice.
- Some pizzaiolos like to finish with a drizzle of hot honey or a sprinkle of Parmesan; experiment to your taste.
- Pair with a side salad dressed in sharp vinaigrette to cut the richness of the pie.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Can I make the dough ahead of time?
A: Yes. Sicilian pizza dough improves with a slow, cold ferment. Make it up to three days in advance and keep refrigerated until ready to use.
Q: What if I can’t find ‘cup-and-char’ pepperoni?
A: Use the smallest pepperoni you can find and slice it fairly thick. Placing the pepperoni on top of the cheese helps it curl and crisp during baking, though some of the characteristic “cups” may not form.
Q: How do I prevent a soggy crust?
A: Generously oil your pan and, if desired, par-bake the crust before adding cheese and sauce. Always add cheese before sauce to create a moisture barrier.
Q: Can I use fresh mozzarella?
A: Low-moisture mozzarella is preferred for its melt and lack of excess water. Fresh mozzarella may make the crust less crisp.
Q: What if I don’t have a square or quarter-sheet pan?
A: Any heavy, rimmed metal baking pan will work. The shape won’t affect the taste, though the classic presentation is square or rectangular.
Nutritional and Allergen Notes
- Dairy: Contains cheese—substitute vegan alternatives as needed.
- Gluten: High-gluten flour is essential for classic texture but gluten-free flour blend may be substituted with recipe adaptations.
- Pork: Traditional pepperoni is pork-based; look for turkey or plant-based versions for dietary restrictions.
- Spice Level: Adjust red pepper flakes and pepperoni quantity to taste.
Final Thoughts: Bringing Spicy Spring Home
Spicy Spring Sicilian pizza is a celebration of crowd-pleasing flavors and textures—crisp, airy crust; bold, bright sauce; overflowing pepperoni; and creamy, gooey cheese. The keys to success lie in patience, quality ingredients, and embracing the generous, robust spirit of classic New York pizzerias. With the right technique and creativity, your kitchen can turn out a pizza worthy of Prince Street’s legendary square.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
