Big Green Egg Kamado Grill Review: One-Year Expert Insights
Achieve precise heat control and rich flavor for searing, smoking, and baking outdoors.
Big Green Egg Kamado Grill Review: A Year of Hands-On Testing
The Big Green Egg has a mythical reputation in the world of grilling and backyard cooking. It’s a familiar sight at barbecues, lauded by home cooks and competition veterans alike. But does the reality match the lasting hype? After a full year of grilling, smoking, baking, and tinkering, this review covers everything you need to know before buying or upgrading to the Big Green Egg.
What is the Big Green Egg?
The Big Green Egg (BGE) is a ceramic kamado-style grill, drawing inspiration from ancient Japanese cooking vessels. Its robust, oval shape and thick walls make it instantly recognizable—and highly effective at maintaining consistent heat for a variety of cooking methods.
- Design: Domed ceramic shell with a hinged lid, grill grates, bottom air intake, top vent, and sturdy metal base (called the “Nest”).
- Function: Can grill, smoke, roast, and bake. A true all-in-one outdoor cooker.
- Sizes: Ranges from the portable Mini to the massive 2XL, with the Large model being the most popular for families and backyard enthusiasts.
Initial Setup and First Impressions
Unboxing the Big Green Egg is an event. The grill is heavy (the Large version weighs around 162 pounds) and built like a tank. Assembly, thankfully, is more straightforward than many gas or pellet grills. Key impressions upon setup:
- Assembly: The Egg arrives mostly preassembled, aside from attaching the handle, bands, and setting it in the base. High-quality hardware and attention to detail make for a surprisingly satisfying (and non-frustrating) experience.
- Build Quality: The thick ceramic walls, sturdy hinges, felt gasket, and all-metal hardware exude durability.
- Footprint: The Large model, with shelves extended, takes up a fair amount of patio or deck space—but this can be a positive if you do lots of entertaining.
The Egg Community
Becoming an Egg owner means joining a passionate, knowledgeable, and sometimes quirky global community. “Eggheads,” as fans call themselves, are known for sharing techniques, recipes, and modifications. This support network is a valuable resource for new users.
Cooking Experience: Grilling, Smoking, and Baking
What truly sets the Big Green Egg apart is its versatility. Over a year, this grill proved itself on burgers, ribeyes, brisket, pizza, vegetables, and even desserts. Here’s a breakdown of the cooking experience by method:
Direct Grilling
The Egg shines for high-heat, direct grilling. Whether searing steaks or charring vegetables, it’s easy to achieve intense heat—well beyond what most gas grills can reach.
- Startup time: With lump charcoal and proper airflow, the Egg reaches 600°F in 20-30 minutes.
- Heat retention: The ceramic shell stores and radiates heat, yielding juicy results with deep caramelization.
- Control: Adjusting the top and bottom vents gives precise temperature control, though there’s a learning curve for beginners.
What others are reading
Smoking and Low-and-Slow
Arguably the Egg’s best trick, smoking at low temperatures (225-275°F) is where its ceramic insulation excels. Brisket, pork shoulder, and whole chickens emerge with deliciously moist interiors and smoky bark.
- Fuel efficiency: The tight seal and thick ceramics mean long cooks require surprisingly little charcoal.
- Stability: Temperatures remain remarkably steady for 6+ hours when set up correctly.
- Flavor: Adding hardwood chunks delivers powerful smoke flavor without excessive bitterness.
Baking and Pizza
The Egg’s ability to act like a wood-fired oven is a standout feature. With a ceramic heat diffuser (“convEGGtor”) in place, you can bake pizzas, bread, and even pies at high temperatures.
- Crusts: Charred, blistered pizza crust is readily achievable.
- Baking bread: The even, radiant heat mimics professional ovens for excellent loaves.
Temperature Control and Learning Curve
The Egg’s dual vent system enables wide temperature flexibility. However, precise control takes practice. Key hints learned from a year of use:
- Vent adjustments: Small changes have big impacts; patience is required when dialing in target temps.
- Recovery: Overshooting the temperature can take time to correct due to the Egg’s heat-retaining ceramics.
- Startup: Use a charcoal chimney or fire starter cubes for consistent lighting without chemical flavors.
Accessories and Customization
The Big Green Egg ecosystem boasts a dazzling array of accessories—called “EGGcessories”—designed to enhance its already impressive functionality:
- convEGGtor: A ceramic plate that turns the Egg into a smoker or convection oven.
- Pizza stone: For crisp, blistered pizza crusts and artisan bread.
- Cast iron grill grates: For improved searing and grill marks.
- Racks, baskets, rotisseries: For multi-zone cooking or roasting.
- Tables, nests, and shelves: For storage, stability, and prep space.
While these extras add to the Egg’s capability, costs can add up quickly. Most users start with the basics and gradually build out their set-up depending on interest and frequency of use.
Durability and Maintenance
Throughout a year of use in all weather conditions, the Big Green Egg proved highly durable. Its ceramics resist rust and corrosion better than most metal grills, but there are important care tips:
- Clean-out door and vent: Regular ash removal is required for optimal airflow and performance.
- Gasket: The felt gasket is a sacrificial part and may eventually need replacement.
- Ceramic care: Take care not to drop dome components, as ceramics—while strong—can crack or chip under impact.
Routine upkeep is minimal compared to many gas or pellet grills. A good brush and an occasional deep clean keep the Egg in top condition for years, if not decades.
Performance: Strengths and Weaknesses
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|
|
|
Value and Cost Consideration
The Big Green Egg is a premium investment, often costing significantly more than conventional charcoal or gas grills—especially once accessories are factored in. However, several factors contribute to its value:
- Longevity: With proper care, an Egg can last for decades. Many owners report using the same grill for 10+ years with minimal issues.
- Support: The manufacturer offers a strong warranty and responsive customer service.
- Performance: The Egg can frequently replace multiple outdoor cooking devices due to its versatility.
For heavy grillers and those who love the process as much as the results, the Egg’s higher price becomes easier to justify over time.
Who Should Buy the Big Green Egg?
The Big Green Egg is best suited for:
- Outdoor cooking enthusiasts willing to invest in quality and experiment with advanced techniques.
- Families, entertainers, and frequent grillers looking for all-in-one functionality in their backyard kitchens.
- Lovers of smoked meats and artisan pizza who value charcoal flavor and true wood-fired results.
It may be less ideal for those who:
- Want instant, hands-off convenience above all (gas/pellet grills may be better).
- Have limited patio space or need portable grills for travel/picnics.
Comparison: Big Green Egg vs. Other Kamado Grills
| Feature | Big Green Egg | Other Kamados |
|---|---|---|
| Build Quality | Exceptional | Varies, often very good |
| Heat Retention | Excellent | Excellent |
| Community/Support | Large, active community | Smaller, less centralized |
| Price | Premium | Ranges from affordable to premium |
| Warranty | Strong, long-term | Varies by brand |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is the Big Green Egg worth the money?
A: For dedicated grillers who value durability, versatility, and flavor, the Big Green Egg generally justifies its cost through years of reliable and flexible performance.
Q: How hard is it to maintain consistent temperature in the Egg?
A: There’s a bit of a learning curve, but with practice, vent adjustments become almost second nature. The ceramics actually help stabilize temperatures once set.
Q: Can I use regular charcoal in the Egg?
A: It’s best to use lump charcoal. Avoid briquettes and lighter fluid, as they can clog air vents and leave unwanted flavors.
Q: Is the Egg truly suitable for baking?
A: Yes. With accessories like the convEGGtor and a pizza stone, it produces excellent bread, pizza, and even desserts with a crisp crust and moist crumb.
Q: Does the Big Green Egg require any electrical or gas connections?
A: No, it is 100% charcoal-fueled and requires no electricity or gas.
Final Thoughts
The Big Green Egg lives up to its reputation as a grilling, smoking, and baking powerhouse. Its legendary heat retention, versatility, and durability make it a favorite for serious backyard cooking enthusiasts. While the price and weight may give some buyers pause, its performance and longevity more than reward the investment for those willing to master its nuances. Over one year of near-constant use, the Egg emerged as a fixture of outdoor cooking—reliable, adaptable, and beloved by everyone it fed. For those seeking the pinnacle of kamado-style grilling, the Big Green Egg is a hard act to beat.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Shinta
