Home » Environment

Will an Electric Car Save You Money? EV Costs Versus Gasoline Cars

Examining the real-world costs, savings, and factors that determine if owning an electric car is financially beneficial.

By Medha deb

Created on Sep 27, 2025

Examining the real-world costs, savings, and factors that determine if owning an electric car is financially beneficial.

Interest in electric vehicles (EVs) is experiencing rapid growth as more drivers look to reduce both their environmental impact and their long-term expenses. But when it comes to personal finance, a key question remains: Will switching to an EV actually save you money compared to a gasoline car? Assessing this question requires understanding a range of cost categories, incentives, and evolving market factors. Below, we dive into the real numbers, comparing EVs and traditional vehicles across upfront costs, fuel and maintenance, tax incentives, resale value, and more.

Upfront Costs: Purchase Price of Electric vs. Gasoline Cars

Historically, EVs have been more expensive to purchase than gasoline cars, primarily because of battery costs. However, this gap is shrinking:

Battery prices have declined significantly in recent years due to improved production scale and technology.
Economies of scale and growing competition have increased the number of affordable EV models, especially in entry-level and compact segments.
Government tax credits and rebates (at national, state, and local levels) can further reduce the sticker price for new EV buyers, sometimes cutting thousands off the initial purchase cost.

It’s important to factor in the total cost beyond the purchase price, however, as EVs often make up for higher upfront costs with lower running expenses over time.

Charging vs. Fuel: What Does It Cost to “Fill Up” an EV?

The running cost of an EV is typically much lower than for gasoline vehicles, due to the price of electricity per mile driven:

Fuel Costs (Gasoline): The average American pays about $2,000 annually for gasoline.
(source: ACEEE, U.S. Department of Energy)
Charging Costs (EVs): For a typical EV averaging 2.5 miles per kWh, annual charging costs are roughly $960. If you drive a more efficient EV (like the Tesla Model Y at 3.5 mi/kWh), that drops to about $680 per year, a savings of about 29% over the less efficient EV and over 60% compared to gasoline.
(source: ACEEE)

Charging costs can vary depending on:

How often you charge at home vs. public stations (home is usually cheaper, especially with off-peak electricity rates).
Electricity rates in your region and whether you can take advantage of time-of-use or renewable energy charging plans.
The energy efficiency of your EV model (measured in miles per kWh).

Some public charging stations are free or offer discounted rates, but others may charge by the minute or by the kWh. Always check local infrastructure options before purchase.

Maintenance and Servicing: Why EVs Tend to Cost Less

Maintenance is another significant area where electric vehicles have a strong advantage over conventional cars. Key factors include:

Fewer moving parts: Electric motors and drivetrains have fewer components than internal combustion engines, resulting in lower risk of wear and tear.
No oil changes or exhaust system problems: EVs don’t require oil changes or maintenance for components like spark plugs, timing belts, or mufflers.
According to U.S. Department of Energy data, maintenance costs for EVs can be about 40% lower than those for a typical gasoline-powered vehicle.

However, certain costs unique to EVs, such as battery degradation and eventual replacement, should be considered for cars kept long-term (typically beyond eight years).

Tax Credits, Incentives, and State Rebates: Cutting the Sticker Price

Government policies play a crucial role in making EVs more accessible:

Federal Tax Credits: In the U.S., new EV buyers may be eligible for a tax credit of up to $7,500, depending on the manufacturer, battery size, and income limits.
State and Local Incentives: Many U.S. states, as well as some cities and utilities, offer additional rebates or perks such as HOV lane access, free parking, or reduced vehicle registration fees.

Incentives can substantially lower the effective upfront cost, but rules and eligibility can be complex. Always check the latest federal and local policies before making a purchase decision.

Depreciation and Resale Value: How Quickly Does an EV Lose Value?

Depreciation—the rate at which a vehicle loses market value over time—is a major factor in total ownership cost. Here’s how it breaks down for EVs and gasoline cars:

Early-generation EVs depreciated quickly, in part because of rapid advances in battery technology and limited demand in the used market.
Resale values for newer EVs are improving as battery warranties stretch longer and as used EV demand rises. Automakers are extending battery warranties, sometimes up to eight to ten years, boosting buyer confidence.
Popular hybrids and long-range EVs tend to retain value better than older, low-range models.

Remember that federal tax credits are not available to used EV purchasers, and resale markets can vary by region.

Comparing Lifetime Ownership Costs: EV vs. Gasoline

When evaluating total cost of ownership (TCO), take into account the following components:

Cost Category	Electric Vehicle (EV)	Gasoline Vehicle
Purchase Price	Often higher (before incentives), becoming more competitive	Lower, especially for entry-level models
Available Incentives	Federal tax credits and local rebates	Limited; some hybrids qualify for smaller incentives
Fuel/Charging Cost	Lower, averages $680-$960 annually	Higher, averages $2,000 annually (varies with prices)
Maintenance	About 40% less expensive	More frequent, more systems to service
Depreciation	Rapid for early models; improving for current EVs	Varies by make/model; hybrids can retain value well
Total Ownership Cost (15 years)	Slightly lower to similar, depending on specific vehicle and usage	Slightly higher to similar

According to recent Department of Energy research, EVs are slightly cheaper to operate per mile (example: 45.08 cents for small SUV hybrids vs. 47.27 cents for gasoline), and can offer still greater savings as battery costs fall and charging infrastructure becomes more widespread.

Real-World Factors That Affect EV Savings

Your personal financial outcome will depend on a variety of variables:

Driving Patterns: If you log most of your miles on highways or drive long distances regularly, an efficient gasoline vehicle or a plug-in hybrid may compete closely with an EV. Daily commuters and city drivers generally see the biggest savings with electric.
Regional Energy Costs: The price of electricity versus fuel can vary dramatically based on where you live, state charging policies, and time-of-use rates.
Charging Habits: Homeowners with access to at-home charging, especially those with solar panels or off-peak utility programs, realize the greatest savings. Apartment dwellers reliant on public stations may face higher ongoing costs.
Government Incentives: Always verify which incentives you personally qualify for, as some phase out with manufacturer sales or have income restrictions.

Reducing Costs Further: Efficient EV Designs

EV efficiency varies widely depending on design. For example, the Hyundai Ioniq 6 achieves 4.2 mi/kWh, the Lucid Air Pure reaches 5 mi/kWh, while less efficient models like the GMC Hummer EV offer just 1.4 mi/kWh. Improved efficiency translates directly to lower battery costs, lower energy bills, and lighter environmental impact.

Other Considerations: Insurance and Battery Replacement

Insurance: EV insurance can be higher due to technology and repair costs, although this difference is closing as EVs become more mainstream and insurers gain expertise.
Battery Replacement: While modern batteries are designed to last 8-10 years or more, replacement can be expensive if needed outside the warranty. However, warranties are getting longer and real-world data shows many batteries outlasting original estimates.

Additionally, there are indirect financial benefits, such as reduced emissions taxes or congestion charges in cities moving towards low-emission or zero-emission zones.

Environmental Benefits: Saving Money and the Planet

While the financial argument is strong for many buyers, the environmental benefits of driving electric—including reduced greenhouse gas emissions and lower local air pollution—are significant. Charging from renewable electricity sources can further enhance these positive impacts.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How long does it take to break even on an EV?

The payback period to offset an EV’s higher upfront cost with savings on fuel and maintenance typically ranges from 3 to 7 years, depending on model, driving habits, and incentives.

Are used electric cars a good deal?

Yes, in some markets—especially as battery warranties improve and depreciation slows for newer models. However, check battery health and consider future replacement costs.

Can I charge an EV with solar panels at home?

Absolutely. Many EV owners install home solar panels to maximize environmental savings and minimize grid costs. This is especially effective with time-of-use charging plans.

Do EVs need special maintenance?

Routine maintenance is generally lower and simpler. Key service items include tire care, brake fluid replacement (less frequent due to regenerative braking), and cabin air filters.

What happens if I run out of charge?

Like running out of gasoline, the vehicle will stop. Roadside assistance, tow services, and mobile chargers are increasingly available, but careful trip planning is essential, especially on long journeys.

Conclusion

For many drivers, electric vehicles provide a meaningful financial advantage over traditional gasoline cars as part of a total cost of ownership calculation. Thanks to rapidly falling battery costs, improved efficiency, and a growing network of incentives, this advantage is expected to strengthen in the coming years. However, the exact amount you’ll save depends on a detailed analysis of your driving habits, energy costs, available incentives, and vehicle choice. As technology and policy continue to evolve, watching these trends will be key for the most financially and environmentally sound vehicle decision.

References

Author

medha deb

Medha Deb is an editor with a master's degree in Applied Linguistics from the University of Hyderabad. She believes that her qualification has helped her develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts.

Read full bio of medha deb