The Real Problems with Desalination: Why Turning Saltwater into Freshwater Isn’t Always the Solution
Desalination transforms seawater into freshwater, but comes with significant environmental, economic, and sustainability challenges.

Understanding Desalination: Promise and Problems
For drought-prone coastal regions around the world, desalination—the process of removing salt and other impurities from seawater to produce freshwater—promises a technological fix to water scarcity. Nations like Saudi Arabia, Australia, Israel, and the United States (particularly California), have invested heavily in this technology to supplement local water supplies. However, despite its increasing popularity, desalination is far from a perfect solution. The process raises a host of environmental, technical, and economic issues that complicate its role as a sustainable answer to water shortages.
How Does Desalination Work?
Desalination typically uses one of two main methods:
- Reverse Osmosis (RO): This method pushes seawater through a series of fine membranes that filter out salt and other impurities. RO is the dominant technology in modern plants, as it’s generally more energy-efficient than thermal methods.
- Thermal Distillation (e.g., Multi-Stage Flash, Multi-Effect Distillation): Seawater is heated until it evaporates, leaving salts and minerals behind. The vapor is then condensed into freshwater.
Other emerging methods include electrodialysis, forward osmosis, and solar desalination, but these are generally used on a smaller scale or for specific applications. Regardless of technology, all desalination plants must address a common cycle: seawater in, freshwater out, and a concentrated brine as waste. This waste stream and the energy required to drive the process lie at the heart of desalination’s problems.
Desalination’s Extreme Energy Demands
One of the most significant drawbacks of desalination is its high energy consumption. Modern reverse osmosis plants require about 15,000 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity to produce one million gallons of freshwater — nearly double the energy needed to recycle and treat wastewater, which averages about 8,300 kWh for the same volume.
- Fossil Fuel Dependency: In many cases, desalination plants run on diesel or other fossil fuels, which means that every gallon of freshwater produced comes with a substantial carbon footprint.
- Greenhouse Gas Emissions: The vast energy requirements result in notable greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, exacerbating climate change at a time when rapid decarbonization is urgently needed.
- Inefficiency: The energy used is primarily for pressurizing water (RO) or heating it (distillation), both inherently energy-hungry activities.
Even where renewable energy can be employed, the continuous, high-energy needs of desalination can strain local grids and compete with other vital electricity demands.
Brine Disposal and Marine Pollution
Desalination doesn’t just create freshwater—it also produces a vast quantity of concentrated brine. This brine contains:
- Salts at concentrations 1.5 to 2 times higher than seawater
- Chemical residues (e.g., anti-scaling agents, cleaning chemicals, metals leached from plant components)
- Heavy metals and other contaminants removed during pretreatment
The disposal of this brine back into the ocean poses a major threat to marine ecosystems:
- Salinity Shock: The brine, being denser and saltier, often sinks to the sea floor, harming benthic organisms (those living on or near the seabed) and altering local habitats.
- Temperature Effects: Especially in thermal desalination, the discharged water is significantly warmer than surrounding seawater, compounding stress for marine life.
- Chemical Contamination: Anti-fouling agents, chlorine, and other chemicals used in the process can be toxic to marine plants and animals.
- Plume Dynamics: The interaction of brine and seawater depends on local currents, topography, and outflow design. Inadequate mixing or dispersal can result in local dead zones or long-term ecosystem shifts.
Technical and Infrastructure Challenges
Desalination isn’t just about separating salt from water. The process comes with several operational and maintenance headaches:
- Pretreatment: Seawater contains not just salt, but also organic matter, sand, silt, algae, and industrial pollutants. Pretreatment removes these contaminants, involving energy-intensive filtration and chemicals.
- Membrane Fouling: Reverse osmosis membranes or thermal evaporators can become clogged or damaged by organic and inorganic particles, demanding regular cleaning, replacement, and system downtime.
- Post-treatment: The resulting freshwater often lacks minerals essential for human health and water system stability. Plants must ‘re-mineralize’ the product water and disinfect it before distribution.
Each step involves specialized equipment, chemical inputs, and trained operators, increasing both capital costs and vulnerability to supply chain disruptions.
Wider Environmental Impacts
Beyond brine discharge and energy use, desalination plants affect their environments in several less obvious ways:
- Intake Impacts: Drawing in seawater can trap and kill plankton, fish larvae, and other small marine organisms, disrupting local food webs.
- Noise Pollution: Large desalination facilities and their infrastructure create industrial noise, impacting both marine and terrestrial species.
- Land Use: Facilities must be built near coastlines, resulting in habitat conversion, increased urbanization, and possible impacts on sensitive coastal ecosystems.
- Cumulative Effects: If many desalination plants operate in a single region, the combined environmental burdens—salinity increases, chemical buildup, temperature changes—can exceed the resilience of local ecosystems.
Economic and Social Costs
The cost of freshwater from desalination is substantial. Key economic hurdles include:
- High Capital Investment: Plants are expensive to build, operate, and maintain.
- Operational Expenses: High energy bills are a persistent burden. Filter and membrane replacements, chemical procurement, regular system maintenance, and brine handling all add to long-term costs.
- Water Price: The price per unit of desalinated water is typically two to five times that of conventional groundwater, river, or reservoir supplies, making it unaffordable for many communities without significant subsidies.
- Inequality: The high cost of desalinated water often restricts its use to wealthier urban areas, while marginalized rural populations can be left behind.
Recent research is exploring innovations like solar-driven desalination and more efficient membrane technologies, but these methods are still less cost-competitive at scale compared to conventional water sources.
Long-Term Sustainability: Is Desalination the Answer?
While desalination offers a technological lifeline for water-stressed regions, its long-term sustainability is questionable. Concerns include:
- Unsustainable Energy Footprint: Unless run on renewable energy, desalination remains a heavy emitter of GHGs, undercutting global climate goals.
- Resource Competition: Desalination can draw valuable resources away from more cost-effective options, such as water conservation, leak repair, wastewater recycling, and aquifer recharge.
- Potential for Environmental Degradation: The combined impacts of brine disposal, chemical use, and land conversion can cause significant, sometimes irreversible, harm to coastal and marine ecosystems.
- Unknown Cumulative Effects: As more plants come online, the long-term consequences of large-scale brine disposal on ocean chemistry and biology remain uncertain.
There is consensus among environmental scientists and engineers that desalination should be treated as a last-resort, to be used in combination with aggressive water conservation and reuse strategies, and preferably powered by low-carbon energy sources.
Can New Technologies Solve Desalination’s Problems?
Recent advancements show some promise for reducing desalination’s negatives, including efforts to:
- Develop solar-powered desalination arrays that dramatically lower energy input.
- Engineer new membrane materials to reduce fouling and extension operating life.
- Design outfall systems and brine management strategies that better disperse waste and minimize local ecosystem impacts.
- Explore beneficial uses of brine byproducts, such as extracting minerals or salts for commercial use.
However, while such innovations are encouraging, most are at the pilot or early commercialization stage. Large-scale desalination remains resource-intensive and complex.
Comparing Desalination to Other Water Solutions
Solution | Energy Use | Environmental Impact | Cost | Scalability |
---|---|---|---|---|
Desalination | High | Significant (brine, GHG, intake) | High | Best for coastal cities |
Wastewater Recycling | Medium | Lower (nutrient management needed) | Medium | Urban/rural |
Water Conservation | Low | Minimal (potential net benefit) | Low | Universal |
Rainwater Harvesting | Low | Minimal | Low | Regional |
Importation | Medium-High | Infrastructure, loss along pipelines | High | Limited |
The Soil and Agriculture Angle
Desalinated water is increasingly used for irrigation in certain water-scarce regions. However, this practice carries hidden risks:
- Soil Degradation: Desalinated water often has a high sodium content, which can degrade soil structure and limit its ability to support healthy crops over time.
- Boron Toxicity: Elevated boron levels, sometimes found in desalinated water, can be toxic to sensitive crops.
- Calcium and Magnesium Deficiency: Essential minerals removed during desalination must be replaced through careful management to avoid negative impacts on soil and plant health.
Managing these issues requires additional interventions—blending with other water sources, leaching excess salts, and adjusting fertilizer regimes—adding further cost and complexity.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Desalination
Q: Is desalinated water safe to drink?
A: Yes, when properly processed and remineralized, desalinated water meets or exceeds drinking water standards. However, improper post-treatment could result in water lacking essential minerals or containing residual chemicals.
Q: Can desalination solve global water shortages?
A: Desalination can provide relief for individual regions, especially coastal cities, but its cost, energy demands, and environmental impacts make it an impractical solution for global freshwater scarcity.
Q: What happens to the brine produced by desalination?
A: Most brine is discharged back into the ocean, where its higher salt concentration and chemical residues can harm marine life and disrupt ecosystems. Safer brine management is an ongoing challenge.
Q: Are there “green” desalination options?
A: New projects experiment with solar- or wind-powered plants, more efficient membranes, and options for beneficial brine reuse. However, these technologies are not yet widespread or proven at scale.
Q: Why not rely more on water conservation or recycling?
A: Conservation and recycling are nearly always more energy- and cost-efficient. Desalination should be reserved for situations where other measures cannot meet essential water needs.
Conclusion: Desalination’s Place in Water Management
Desalination is, at best, a short-term emergency measure or a supplemental supply for wealthy, coastal regions with few alternatives. It requires significant resources, poses real environmental hazards, and is unlikely to replace less expensive, more sustainable solutions such as conservation, recycling, and efficient water use. As technology advances, the hope is that future desalination methods will become cleaner, cheaper, and less ecologically damaging, but for now, communities should prioritize the full portfolio of water solutions before turning to desalination.
References
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10698098/
- https://www.weforum.org/stories/2022/12/desalination-process-freshwater-negative-environmental-cost/
- https://news.mit.edu/2023/desalination-system-could-produce-freshwater-cheaper-0927
- https://practical.engineering/blog/2023/6/28/why-is-desalination-so-difficult
- https://www.eesi.org/articles/view/whats-the-deal-with-desalination
Read full bio of Sneha Tete