Gene-Edited Hens: A Scientific Breakthrough to End Male Chick Culling
Innovative gene-editing methods may soon end the mass culling of male chicks, transforming animal welfare and egg production.
The worldwide egg industry faces a longstanding ethical and environmental dilemma: every year, billions of male chicks born to layer hens are systematically culled shortly after hatching because they do not produce eggs and are unsuited for meat production. Scientists have long sought humane and practical solutions to this problem. In a groundbreaking development, researchers have used gene-editing technology to create hens that ensure only female chicks hatch, potentially eliminating the need for male chick culling in the egg industry.
Why Are Male Chicks Culled?
Chickens are the most numerous livestock species worldwide, with a staggering population exceeding 23 billion. For every hen bred to lay eggs, about half her chicks will be male—and in most layer breeds, these males do not have enough meat value to be raised for food. Thus, the egg industry is left with billions of male chicks each year that have little use within current production systems.
- Egg-laying breeds are genetically optimized for maximum egg production, making their male offspring inefficient for meat compared to broiler breeds.
- Standard practices for culling include gassing and maceration (immediate destruction using mechanical devices), both of which have raised significant animal welfare concerns globally.
- Scale: Estimates indicate that as many as seven billion male chicks are culled annually across the globe.
The Science Behind Gene-Edited Hens
Israeli researchers at the Volcani Center, an institute affiliated with Israel’s Ministry of Agriculture, have pioneered a solution with the development of genetically engineered hens—dubbed the Golda hen—that only produce female chicks for the next generation . This innovation centers on precise gene editing and an ingenious use of light-triggered gene expression.
How Does the Technology Work?
- Using gene-editing tools, the scientists modified the sex-determining Z chromosome in hens.
- When eggs are fertilized, the genetic modification causes only male embryos to become sensitive to exposure to a specific blue light frequency at an early stage.
- Female embryos remain unaffected by this light, developing normally into healthy chicks.
- Blue light exposure during incubation ensures that only viable female chicks hatch, as male embryos cease development early.
Crucially, both the resulting chicks and the eggs produced for human consumption are free from any added foreign genetic material. This means consumers receive products that are biologically comparable to traditional eggs and layer hens .
Implications for Animal Welfare and Industry
Ending the mass-killing of male chicks represents a monumental step forward for animal welfare. Global animal advocacy organizations, which have historically opposed the genetic modification of livestock, see this case as a unique and ethically compelling exception .
- Compassion in World Farming (CIWF), a leading animal welfare NGO, has openly supported this development, with advisor Peter Stephenson calling it a “really important” step for animal welfare.
- Dr. Yuval Cinnamon, chef scientist at the Volcani Center, underscored the potential: “I am very happy that we have developed a system that I think can truly revolutionize the industry, first of all for the benefit of the chickens but also for all of us, because this is an issue that affects every person on the planet.”
What others are reading
Regulatory and Industry Momentum
- Germany and France became the first nations to prohibit all chick culling starting January 2022, inspiring further legislative action across the European Union .
- Widespread adoption of gene-edited hens could allow producers in these and other regions to comply with legal bans without increased costs or loss of productivity.
- The Volcani Center aims to commercialize the technology through their spin-off company, Huminn Poultry .
Benefits Beyond Animal Welfare
Adopting gene-edited hens to eliminate male chick culling has broad-reaching implications:
- Reduced waste: No resources are spent incubating and killing billions of animals each year.
- Lower costs: Farmers can avoid costly sorting and culling processes, making operations more efficient.
- Environmental impact: Vegetable protein, energy, and water are no longer wasted on short-lived animals, contributing to better overall resource management.
- Public trust: Transparent communication about the safety and ethical soundness of the technology supports growing consumer demand for humane products.
How Does Chicken Sex Determination Work?
Understanding the genetic mechanism behind this advancement requires a look at avian biology:
- Unlike mammals, where males are XY and females are XX, birds use a ZW system; males are ZZ and females are ZW.
- The gene-editing approach targets a specific marker on the Z chromosome that, in presence of blue light, disrupts male embryonic development at a very early stage, while female embryos (ZW) do not express the light-sensitive marker and proceed normally .
Influence of Other Gene-Editing Research
The approach used by the Volcani Center builds on wider efforts in the field of gene editing for both animal welfare and agricultural efficiency. Notably:
- Researchers at the Francis Crick Institute and the University of Kent used a CRISPR-based system in mice to reliably produce litters of only one sex—demonstrating the wider applicability of gene-editing to control sex in non-avian species .
- Australian CSIRO scientists have proposed a different technique utilizing CRISPR to induce fluorescence in male chick eggs. Eggs could be sexed immediately after laying with a laser scanner, allowing early identification and humane disposal of male embryos well before hatching .
The Golda hen’s blue light approach stands out for its practical simplicity and minimal impact on the food product supply.
Potential Risks and Concerns
No new technology is without debate or regulatory scrutiny, and gene-editing in animals–especially those bred for food–remains controversial in some circles. Key points of discussion include:
- Genetic modification stigma: Consumer and regulatory acceptance of genetically edited animals in the food supply varies by country and is often influenced by public perception of GMOs (genetically modified organisms).
- Data sharing and peer review: The Volcani Center team has yet to publish detailed scientific results in a peer-reviewed journal, mainly because they are focused on regulatory approval and commercialization .
- Potential unintended effects: Long-term welfare studies are needed to ensure that modified hens and their offspring do not experience health or productivity issues over multiple generations.
- Transparency: Ongoing communication and open scientific exchange will be necessary to maintain public and regulatory trust.
Regulatory Pathway and Commercial Prospects
For gene-edited hens to reach the global market, several hurdles must be crossed:
- Regulatory review: Food safety authorities in each country must assess the technology’s safety, both for animal welfare and human consumption.
- Labeling: Policy makers and industry will need to agree on appropriate labeling to inform consumers if products originated from genetically edited animals.
- International standards: Harmonizing regulations across countries is important for global food trade and for adoption by multinational egg producers.
The Volcani Center’s licensing efforts through Huminn Poultry signal that commercialization may soon be within reach, at least in some regulatory environments .
Table: Key Differences Between Current and Proposed Methods
| Aspect | Traditional Industry Practice | Gene-Edited Hens Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Sex Selection | Sorting after hatching; manual, labor-intensive | Selection occurs before hatching; only females hatch |
| Male Chick Fate | Culled en masse by gassing or maceration | Male embryos do not develop (do not hatch) |
| Animal Welfare | Poor; widely criticized | Greatly improved; mass culling eliminated |
| Farmer Efficiency | Extra steps and disposal required | Simplified hatching process; reduced waste |
| Genetic Modification of Food | None in eggs or hens | No new DNA in market eggs or hens; only breeding stock are edited |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: How common is male chick culling in modern egg farming?
A: It is standard practice worldwide, with up to seven billion male chicks culled every year due to lack of utility in egg and meat production systems .
Q: Are gene-edited hens and their eggs considered genetically modified organisms (GMOs)?
A: The gene-editing is limited to the initial breeding hen’s Z chromosome and does not transfer to the eggs or female chicks raised for consumption. As such, the final market products are not genetically modified in the conventional sense, though regulations and consumer perceptions may vary .
Q: What are the main animal welfare benefits of this technology?
A: The primary benefit is the elimination of the need to cull live male chicks after hatching. Animals are not subjected to painful or stressful procedures, aligning with growing legal and ethical standards.
Q: Has the technology been independently peer-reviewed?
A: As of now, the technology is undergoing commercialization and regulatory approval. Detailed peer-reviewed studies are pending but anticipated as the technology progresses .
Q: Will consumers notice any difference in eggs produced by these hens?
A: No. Eggs from gene-edited lines are biologically identical to conventional eggs, with no change in nutritional value, taste, or genetic content .
Looking Forward: The Future of Humane Egg Production
The development of hens that hatch only females represents a milestone in reconciling productivity with compassion in agriculture. As regulations and consumer expectations evolve, the successful adoption of gene-edited hens could stand as a model for ethically advancing food production, benefitting animals, producers, and the planet alike. With continued research transparency, regulatory oversight, and public engagement, gene-editing holds the promise to resolve dilemmas once considered insurmountable in the farming world.
References
- https://www.isaaa.org/kc/cropbiotechupdate/ged/article/default.asp?ID=19946
- https://www.zmescience.com/ecology/animals-ecology/billions-of-chicks-are-killed-just-because-theyre-males-gene-edited-hens-could-change-all-that/
- https://www.labroots.com/trending/genetics-and-genomics/24335/gene-editing-spare-billions-chicks
- https://thegoodnewshub.com/animals/chicken-genes-stop-cull-of-male-chicks/
- https://www.cieh.org/ehn/food-safety-integrity/2023/january/gene-edited-hens-may-end-cull-of-billions-of-male-chicks/
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
