Cedars vs. Junipers: Differences, Identification, and Ecology
Explore the unique distinctions, ecological roles, and identification tips for cedars and junipers throughout the world.
Cedars and Junipers: Exploring the Differences
Cedars and junipers are iconic coniferous trees belonging to different genera and even different botanical families. Despite sharing some superficial similarities—evergreen foliage, woody cones, and a reputation for durability—their differences in genetics, leaf structure, habitat, and uses are profound. This article explores the key distinctions, ecological significance, and tips for identifying both native and introduced species of cedars and junipers across North America and beyond.
What Are True Cedars and True Junipers?
To fully appreciate the contrast between cedars and junipers, it’s essential to start with botanical definitions. Many North American trees called “cedar” are not true cedars, and some familiar landscape evergreens are actually junipers. Understanding the true identity of these trees helps clarify their characteristics and ecological roles.
- True Cedars (Genus: Cedrus): Members of the pine family (Pinaceae), true cedars are native to Europe, North Africa, and the Himalayas. Examples include the Lebanon cedar (Cedrus libani), Deodar cedar (Cedrus deodara), and Atlas cedar (Cedrus atlantica).
- Junipers (Genus: Juniperus): Belonging to the cypress family (Cupressaceae), junipers are widely distributed and extremely diverse, with around 70 species worldwide.
- “Cedars” in North America: Many so-called “cedars”—such as eastern redcedar and western redcedar—are actually junipers or other cypress relatives.
True Cedars: An Overview
True cedars are not native to North America. They have needle-like leaves arranged in clusters and produce large, upright woody cones. Their timber has been prized since antiquity for construction and shipbuilding due to its toughness and aromatic qualities. Notable features:
- Needle-shaped leaves grouped in clusters
- Woody, barrel-shaped cones held upright on branches
- Native to the mountains of the Mediterranean and Himalayas
What About “Cedars” of North America?
In North America, the name “cedar” is commonly (but incorrectly) applied to:
- Eastern redcedar (Juniperus virginiana), a juniper
- Western redcedar (Thuja plicata), in the cypress family
- Alaska cedar (Callitropsis nootkatensis), also a cypress relative
- Incense cedar (Calocedrus decurrens), another cypress family member
None of these are actually true cedars, even though their common names and timber products use the term.
Junipers: A Diverse Group
Junipers are a widespread and highly variable group, ranging from ground-hugging shrubs to towering trees. Notable for their tough, scale-like leaves and their berry-like seed cones, junipers thrive in a range of climates from deserts to mountain slopes.
- Leaves are either needle-like (in young or fast-growing shoots) or scale-like (in mature plants)
- Produce berry-like, often blue seed cones consumed by wildlife
- Extremely durable in drought and poor soils
How to Identify Cedars and Junipers: Key Characteristics
Although they are often confused in landscaping and wild settings, cedars and junipers can be distinguished by examining several key features:
What others are reading
| Feature | Cedars | Junipers |
|---|---|---|
| Leaves | Needle-like, in tufts or clusters | Scale-like or needle-like, pressed on twig |
| Cones | Woody, barrel-shaped, upright | Fleshy, berry-like (blue or purple), small |
| Native Range | Mediterranean, Himalayas | Worldwide, esp. North America, Eurasia |
| Aroma | Strong, spicy, “incense” scent | Often aromatic, sometimes “gin” scented |
| Wood | Light, durable, aromatic | Durable, aromatic, used for fenceposts, lining |
Paying close attention to the structure of the leaves, the orientation and shape of cones, and scent of the wood are all helpful in proper identification. Many day-to-day “cedars,” especially in gardens and parks in North America, are actually junipers or cypress relatives.
Geographic Range and Habitat
True Cedars
True cedars grow natively on dry, mountainous slopes:
- Lebanon Cedar (Cedrus libani): Mountains of Lebanon, western Syria, southern Turkey
- Atlas Cedar (Cedrus atlantica): Atlas Mountains of Morocco and Algeria
- Deodar Cedar (Cedrus deodara): Western Himalayas (Afghanistan, northern India, Nepal, Pakistan)
- Cyprus Cedar (Cedrus brevifolia): Mountains of Cyprus
These trees are adapted to rocky, dry, well-drained soils and are commonly planted as ornamentals in Europe and North America, though never naturalized.
Junipers
Junipers have one of the widest natural distributions among conifers:
- North America: Eastern redcedar (Juniperus virginiana), Rocky Mountain juniper (Juniperus scopulorum), and many shrub forms
- Eurasia: Common juniper (Juniperus communis), various Mediterranean and Asian species
- Habitats range from deserts to alkaline flats, hillsides, and open forests
- Extremely tolerant of poor, rocky, or sandy soils and high variation in moisture levels
Native American “Cedar”: Eastern Redcedar
The “eastern redcedar” is in fact a native juniper (Juniperus virginiana), and it is abundant across the eastern and central United States. Its adaptability allows it to thrive in conditions that thwart many other tree species, from abandoned fields to fencerows and along highways.
- Tolerant of drought, heat, cold, wind, salt, and a variety of soils
- Can be invasive in grasslands and prairies where allowed to seed freely
- Provides critical winter shelter and food for wildlife, including the Cedar Waxwing (named for this tree)
Leaf Structure: Needles and Scales
Cedars
True cedar leaves grow in needle-like clusters attached to short pegs on the twigs. The needles are soft, flexible, and can be arranged in spirals or whorls, giving branches a lush look.
Junipers
Juniper foliage is quite variable. Young shoots often have short, pointed, needle-like leaves, while mature branches bear flattened, scale-like leaves pressed close to the twigs—similar to what you might find on arborvitae or cypress.
- Needle leaves on juvenile growth
- Scale leaves dominate on older, mature portions
Reproductive Structures: Cones and Berries
Cedars
True cedars produce upright, oval-shaped seed cones that can reach several inches in length. These cones sit atop branches, much like those seen on pines, but are barrel-shaped and disintegrate to release seeds.
Junipers
Juniper seed cones are unique—round, berry-like, and often blue or purple. Despite their appearance, these are not true berries but scales fused around the seeds. Many species require a year or more for cones to reach full ripeness, providing food for birds and mammals in winter.
Ecological Importance
Wildlife Value
- Cedar and juniper foliage offers critical cover for small animals during winter.
- Juniper “berries” are a key winter food source for birds, including the Cedar Waxwing, robins, and bluebirds, as well as foxes and other mammals.
- True cedar woodlands in their native range support unique mountain wildlife communities.
Soil, Drought, and Windbreak Roles
- Eastern redcedar (Juniperus virginiana) has been planted as a windbreak and land reclamation tree in the American Midwest, especially after the Dust Bowl, due to its toughness in exposed sites.
- Junipers can colonize poor or eroded soils and stabilize land, but can also become invasive if unmanaged.
- Cedars prefer sites that are moist but not soggy, while junipers excel in well-drained, even dry soils.
Common Problems and Drawbacks
Ecosystem Impacts
- In some regions, the spread of junipers like eastern redcedar threatens native prairie and scrubland habitats by crowding out grasses and reducing biodiversity.
- This weedy tendency is countered by their usefulness for wildlife and their value in stabilizing disrupted landscapes.
Pathogens and Pests
- Eastern redcedar is a host for cedar-apple rust, a fungal disease that can devastate apple, pear, and quince orchards.
- Both cedars and junipers can suffer from winter dehydration if exposed to harsh, reflected sun with roots in frozen soil, especially in poorly chosen urban sites.
Wood, Aroma, and Human Uses
- Cedar wood (from true and “false” cedars) is valued for durability and resistance to insects—used in chests, closets, fencing, and landscaping.
- Juniper wood is aromatic, rot-resistant, and often used for fenceposts, bedding chests, pencils, and even linings for drawers.
- Juniper “berries” are the source of flavor in gin and have been used for medicinal purposes by many cultures.
Cedar vs. Juniper: Quick Reference
| Characteristic | Cedars | Junipers |
|---|---|---|
| Family | Pinaceae (Pine) | Cupressaceae (Cypress) |
| Leaf Type | Needle-like clusters | Scale-like or needle-like |
| Cone Type | Woody and upright | Berry-like and fleshy |
| Notable Species | Cedrus libani, C. deodara | Juniperus virginiana, J. communis |
| Major Uses | Timber, ornamental | Wildlife, fencing, windbreaks |
Conservation, Cultivation, and Care
Recommendations for Gardeners and Landowners
- Choose cedars for constant damp (not soggy) ground, and use mulch to retain moisture.
- Plant junipers where excellent drainage and full sun are available; ideal for tough or dry sites.
- Both benefit from late fall watering to prepare for winter dehydration, particularly in exposed or sunny locations.
- Avoid planting eastern redcedar near apple, pear, or quince trees to reduce risk of cedar-apple rust.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs): Cedars and Junipers
Q: Are eastern redcedar and true cedar the same?
A: No. Eastern redcedar is a native juniper (Juniperus virginiana), not a true member of the cedar genus (Cedrus).
Q: How can I distinguish between a juniper and a cedar tree?
A: Examining the foliage is most helpful—cedars have needle-like leaves in clusters, while junipers have scale-like or needle-like leaves pressed to the twigs. Cone type also helps—woody and upright for cedars, berry-like for junipers.
Q: Why are so many North American trees called “cedar”?
A: Many North American trees share aromatic wood and evergreen foliage with true cedars, but botanically they are junipers or cypress relatives. The common name stuck due to similar properties and appearance.
Q: Are either cedars or junipers invasive?
A: Eastern redcedar (a juniper) can be invasive in prairies and grasslands, spreading quickly in disturbed or unmanaged sites.
Q: What wildlife depend on cedar or juniper trees?
A: Birds (such as the cedar waxwing), small mammals, and insects use these trees for food and shelter—especially in winter. Juniper “berries” are especially important for wildlife diets.
Summary: Key Takeaways
- True cedars (genus Cedrus) are native to Eurasia and North Africa, not North America; most “cedars” here are actually junipers or other cypress family members.
- Junipers (genus Juniperus) are widespread, hardy, and important for wildlife—often misnamed as “cedar.”
- Identification is easiest by comparing foliage and cones: clustered needles and upright cones (cedars) vs. scale-like leaves and berry-like cones (junipers).
- Both have ecological and economic value but differ dramatically in their habitat preferences, native ranges, and potential invasiveness.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of medha deb
