Does One/Size Setting Spray Actually Lock in Makeup? A Deep Dive Review
We tested the viral One/Size On 'Til Dawn Setting Spray for wear, finish, and longevity—here's everything you need to know.
One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray Review
Setting sprays have become a staple in every makeup-lover’s arsenal, promising to hold makeup in place for hours—even through sweat, humidity, and the chaos of daily life. Recently, One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray by Patrick Starrr has taken social media and the beauty world by storm, thanks in part to viral TikTok reviews and celebrity endorsements. But does it truly live up to its claims? We’ve put it to the test in real life and broken down its performance, finish, formula, user experience, and more.
Quick Overview
- Brand: ONE/SIZE by Patrick Starrr
- Type: Waterproof, mattifying, oil-control aerosol setting spray
- Main Claims: Locks in makeup for up to 16 hours, sweat and waterproof, blurs pores, controls oil
- Suitable for: Oily and combination skin, makeup that needs all-day hold
- Price: $32 for 3.4 oz (standard size)
About One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray
Created by influencer and makeup artist Patrick Starrr, the On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray is marketed as a high-performance setting spray with a focus on longevity and oil control. The formula is packed in an aerosol can that emits an ultra-fine mist, aiming to coat your finished makeup with a protective, breathable barrier that is—according to the brand—sweat-proof, waterproof, and rub-proof. It also claims to blur pores and keep shine at bay, making it particularly attractive to those with oily or combination skin.
According to the manufacturer:
- Makeup stays locked in place for 16 hours
- Helps control excess oil and mattify skin
- Waterproof, rub-proof, blurring effect
- Tightens the appearance of pores
- Butane-based propellant complies with EPA safety standards
First Impressions: Application and Formula
Before anything else, the packaging stands out: the aerosol can dispenses a fine mist that gently covers the face. Application instructions are to shake well, hold about 10–12 inches from your face, and spray in circular motions with eyes closed for even coverage. The process feels similar to hairspray—quick and efficient—though it does have a distinct scent that is not universally loved, and some noted the lingering taste if inhaled.
- Mist Quality: Ultra-fine; covers skin evenly
- Scent: Synthetic fragrance that some users dislike
- User Tips: Hold your breath and close your eyes (the spray can be intense)
Note: Some users reported issues with clogged spray mechanisms, though most resolved this by shaking vigorously before use.
Performance: Wear Test and Longevity
We subjected One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray to a battery of tests: full-makeup days, outdoor activities, dancing, and even workouts. Here are the key questions answered:
| Criteria | Observations |
|---|---|
| Longevity | Makeup stayed intact for up to 12–16 hours without significant fading—matching claims. |
| Oil Control | Noticeable reduction in shine and breakthrough, especially on oily skin types. |
| Water/Sweat Resistance | Hold up even through humid conditions, sweat, and light water exposure. Rub-proof in practice. |
| Finish | Matte effect, blurs pores, smoothes texture. No sticky or cakey residue. |
| Transfer Prevention | Less makeup transfer to masks, clothing, or hands compared to most non-aerosol sprays. |
Viral Endorsements: The Beyoncé Factor
A big part of the One/Size spray’s popularity arose after it was revealed that Beyoncé’s makeup team used this exact product on stage during the Renaissance Tour, helping her maintain a flawless look through hours of performing under hot lights. Such testimonials have elevated the spray’s reputation among professionals and enthusiasts alike—which we found warranted in our own trials: makeup really does stay put as promised.
What others are reading
Key Ingredients and Claims
- Alcohol Denat. (quick dry, helps set makeup)
- Magnesium Carbonate (oil-absorption)
- Witch Hazel Water (soothing and tightening)
- Aloe Leaf Juice (calming)
- Cucumber Extract (refreshing)
The combination of oil-absorbing and skin-calming ingredients gives the spray its mattifying, pore-blurring qualities. The formula is primarily alcohol-based, which allows for quick drying, and uses butane and isobutane as propellants. The brand maintains that their aerosol can meets U.S. EPA safety standards and uses butane simply to disperse the spray, with no long-term exposure concerns.
Who Should Use This Setting Spray?
- Oily Skin Types: Those who struggle with excess shine and large pores
- Event-goers: Brides, performers, or anyone needing makeup to last over 8 hours
- Makeup Enthusiasts: Full glam looks requiring strong hold
- Active Lifestyles: Anyone needing makeup to resist sweat, humidity, or water exposure
Tip: Drier or sensitive skin types may find the formula a little too mattifying or drying, so consider hydrating prep or alternating with a dewy-finish spray. There is now a dewy version for those preferring a more natural glow.
Pros and Cons
- Pros:
- Extremely long-lasting wear (up to 16 hours)
- Mattifies and blurs pores for a smooth finish
- Waterproof, sweat-proof—great for events or long days
- Minimizes makeup transfer
- Aerosol mist is fine and covers evenly
- Complies with EPA propellant safety standards
- Cons:
- Scent is strong and not universally liked
- Aerosol can raise environmental concerns
- Can feel drying for sensitive or dry skin types
- Spray mechanism may occasionally clog (shake well to fix)
How Does It Compare to Other Setting Sprays?
To help you decide if One/Size is right for you, here’s how it stacks up against two other top performers:
| Setting Spray | Longevity | Finish | Water Proof? | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One/Size On ‘Til Dawn | 12–16 hrs | Matte | Yes | $32 |
| Urban Decay All Nighter | 8–12 hrs | Natural | Moderate | $36 |
| Milani Make It Last | 6–8 hrs | Dewy/Matte Options | No | $11 |
One/Size delivers the longest wear and strongest waterproof performance, at a higher price point and with a distinct matte effect. Urban Decay All Nighter is the classic favorite for many, with a more balanced finish. Milani’s Make It Last is great for affordability and versatility but won’t match the performance in heat or sweat.
Tips for the Best Results
- Shake well before use to prevent clogging
- Hold 10–12 inches from face and close eyes tightly
- Use before makeup as a priming spray for extra longevity and hydration
- Apply after all makeup (including powders) in one even layer
- For touch-ups, spray onto a sponge and gently pat where needed
- Store upright to maintain can pressure
What Users Say
- “I have dealt with extremely oily skin since puberty. I have tried so many things and nothing helped… UNTIL I FOUND THIS!!! UNBELIEVABLE.”
- “Keeps my make up fresh all day.”
- “Great spray. Makes my make up last, especially in heat.”
- “For some reason the spray doesn’t work. I cannot get the product to come out.” (Tip: Shake vigorously.)
The overwhelming consensus: One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray excels in longevity and performance for those needing makeup to stay put all day. The major downsides reported are related to personal preference on scent, potential drying effect, and aerosol format.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray safe for sensitive skin?
A: The formula contains alcohol and fragrance, which may be drying or irritating for sensitive skin. Patch test before using if you have concerns.
Q: Will this setting spray make my skin feel tight?
A: The mattifying effect can feel slightly tightening, especially if your skin is dry. Pair with hydrating skincare underneath or try the Dewy version if you prefer more moisture.
Q: Is the aerosol propellant safe?
A: According to the manufacturer, the butane and its derivatives used as propellants comply with environmental and health regulations by the EPA. The butane evaporates immediately after dispensing and is not present in the finished spray on your skin.
Q: Does it have a strong scent?
A: Yes, it contains synthetic fragrance that some users find strong. Hold your breath while spraying if scent sensitivity is a concern.
Q: Can I use One/Size Setting Spray with all makeup types?
A: Yes, it works with powder, cream, and liquid formulas, but is optimized for full-face glam and long-wear looks.
Final Thoughts
The One/Size On ‘Til Dawn Setting Spray by Patrick Starrr delivers on its promise of making makeup last through anything—heat, sweat, humidity, long days, and wild nights. Its powerful mattifying effect, waterproof hold, and viral credentials make it a go-to for those with oily skin or who need their makeup to be flawless for many hours. While the aerosol can and scent may deter some, its results are undeniable—and it’s suitably earned its moment as a beauty holy grail for enduring wear.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
