New York Fashion Week: The Push for Diversity and Its Challenges
A detailed exploration of how New York Fashion Week is striving for greater diversity—and the backlash, progress, and realities shaping its runways.
New York Fashion Week and the Ongoing Quest for Diversity
For decades, New York Fashion Week (NYFW) has stood as both a celebration of creativity and a barometer of cultural progress in the fashion world. However, alongside glamour and groundbreaking design, NYFW has long faced criticism for its lack of inclusivity—particularly with respect to race, body type, and social representation. Each season, debates reignite about which groups are present, which are excluded, and whether genuine progress is being made.
This article critically examines NYFW’s journey towards diversity: the public outcry and industry response, the statistics behind model casting, the complex topic of body image, key moments of inclusivity on the runway, and what these evolutions mean for fashion’s future.
The Backdrop: Why Diversity Matters in Fashion
Fashion’s influence extends far beyond the runway. Its images and ideals shape global trends, self-esteem, and socioeconomic access. NYFW—arguably the most high-profile stage in American fashion—sets the tone for what is considered stylish and, by extension, who is desirable, visible, and included.
- When diversity is lacking, fashion reinforces narrow standards of beauty and identity.
- When representation improves, the impact ripples: empowering underrepresented groups, inspiring new consumers, and pushing for change across the industry.
Years of Exclusion: The Historical Struggle
NYFW’s initial decades featured overwhelmingly white, thin, conventionally attractive models. Breaking into this echelon was exceptionally difficult for people of color, plus-size models, or those with non-traditional features. Occasional “token” castings did little to challenge an entrenched status quo.
The post-2010s saw a concerted push from activists, editors, and consumers demanding better. Hashtags like #RunwayForAll and public calls for diversity forced agencies and designers to acknowledge the gap between their marketing and casting practices.
Signs of Progress: Landmark NYFW Moments
In recent years, NYFW has featured defining moments in the pursuit of inclusion. These moments, while promising, have also sparked debate over whether they represent meaningful change or marketing-driven tokenism.
- Cultural Heritage on the Runway: Designers like Brandon Maxwell and Theophilio used their collections to pay homage to Texan, Jamaican, and American heritages, embracing models and aesthetics previously underrepresented on major runways.
- Advocacy Through Fashion: Rachel Antonoff and Susan Alexandra featured models walking with shelter dogs to encourage pet adoption, while collaborations with advocacy organizations like Project Lab Coat redirected runway proceeds toward causes such as Lyme disease research.
- Trendsetting Beyond Aesthetics: Ready-to-wear lines—once exclusive by design—have started to address a broader market, with looser silhouettes and varied styling suggesting greater sensitivity to different body types.
Lack of Diversity Remains: Current Criticisms
Despite headline-grabbing moments and increasing discussions about inclusion, criticism remains forceful—both from fashion insiders and the broader public. The 2025 NYFW was no exception. The following concerns captured widespread attention:
- Limited Racial Diversity: Editorials and opinion pieces noted runways that still heavily favored white, thin models, particularly at larger heritage brands.
- Body Inclusivity: The ongoing “Ozempic obsession”—referring to widespread weight-loss drug usage—has accompanied a visible shift back towards very thin body types, spurring disappointment among advocates for broader size inclusion.
- “Nepo Babies” and Access Barriers: Several shows featured front rows dominated by the children of celebrities and fashion insiders (e.g., Isan Elba, Olivia Jade, Leni Klum), reinforcing concerns that the industry is growing more insular rather than open.
What others are reading
The Numbers: Who’s Really on The Runways?
True progress is measured not in anecdotes, but in data. Each fashion season, watchdogs and journalists tally the demographics of NYFW castings. Independent reviews for 2025 still found a stark underrepresentation of Black, Asian, Latinx, Indigenous, and plus-size models—especially in high-profile shows.
Public reaction has included calls for the Council of Fashion Designers of America (CFDA) and major agencies to adopt more transparent quotas or guidelines for inclusive casting.
Body Image: Progress and Setbacks
Body inclusivity remains perhaps the most visible—and contentious—diversity issue. While previous seasons saw a rise in plus-size model representation (notably the inclusion of trailblazers like Ashley Graham and Paloma Elsesser in top shows), this year saw a partial reversion:
- Sample sizes continue to run small, limiting options for models outside the traditional ideal.
- Few plus-size or visibly curvy models walked for luxury brands; most were cast for independent or niche labels.
- The visible return of very thin models, paired with “wellness” or weight-loss narratives, alienated many audiences who had hoped the moment for inclusivity had finally arrived.
Statements from models themselves, like Ella Halikas, reveal deep frustration: “Each year gets worse and worse, especially with the direction of thinner being ‘in.'”
Beyond the Runway: Fashion’s Broader Influence
NYFW is more than a spectacle—it’s the engine of trends that ripple from high fashion to mass retail. Diversity at the top seeds representation everywhere. Because:
- Retailers set their offerings based on NYFW lineups.
- Media images from the week define beauty standards for seasons to come.
- Emerging designers take cues from what is celebrated—and overlooked—on the biggest runways.
Trends at NYFW 2025: Styles and Statements
This season balanced maximalism and minimalism, with the following key trends making headlines:
- Color Trends: Bright pinks and reds are poised to replace last year’s butter yellow as the must-have shades, accompanied by classic black-and-white contrasts.
- Silhouette Shifts: Loose, unembellished designs with room for interpretation were plentiful, suggesting at least some appeal to a range of body types.
- Patterns & Embellishments: Polka dots (especially in Kathe collections), frequent sequins, and feather accessories.
- Accessories: Silk scarves, bold pendants, and statement jewelry captured the maximalist spirit, infusing both luxe and boho appeal.
The wardrobes seen on city streets during NYFW were equally diverse—reflecting New York’s multicultural pulse—even if the official runways lagged in inclusivity.
The Conversation on Authentic Change vs. Tokenism
Are NYFW’s diversity efforts meaningful, or are they merely token gestures? Critics and supporters disagree:
- Plus: The mere presence of more models of color, a handful of plus-sized women, or advocacy moments marks undeniable progress when compared to earlier years.
- Minus: The frequency of “one and done” bookings (a single plus-size or minority model per show) and reluctance by major houses to make inclusivity standard rather than exceptional points to lingering tokenism.
- Public Skepticism: Fashion insiders and the general audience remain sharply attuned to what feels performative versus transformative.
Reactions from Within the Industry
Designers, models, and critics have spoken out on both sides of the diversity debate. While some brands earn praise, others continue to feature almost exclusively white or conventionally shaped models despite public pressure.
- “Fashion is political, whether we admit it or not.” (Anonymous designer)
- “Representation isn’t just about different faces—it’s about power, opportunity, and who gets to set the standard.” (Fashion editor)
- “It’s time to celebrate true diversity—not as the exception, but the rule.” (Advocate & influencer)
Inclusive Advocacy: Notable Campaigns and Collaborations
Several standout efforts signaled a shift from individual token castings to authentic collaborations:
- Designer Partnerships: Events featured designers joining with nonprofits (such as Project Lab Coat) to support social issues from animal adoption to disease awareness.
- Community Models: Show organizers increasingly invited local talent, non-professional models, and individuals from marginalized groups—though these castings remain rare at the most prestigious events.
NYFW’s Impact Beyond New York
As one of the “Big Four” fashion weeks worldwide, NYFW’s approach to diversity is watched and emulated globally: in Paris, Milan, London, and beyond. Its successes—and failures—set precedents for the entire industry.
Globally renowned designers and powerful new voices continue to debate what the future runway should look like. The outcome affects rising generations of designers and fashion-lovers around the world.
Consumer Response: The Power of Public Pressure
Consumers and social media users hold real sway over today’s fashion narrative. Public backlash over exclusion, calls for boycotts, and amplified praise for inclusive brands influence designers’ decisions and bottom lines. Labels hoping to remain relevant are increasingly forced to heed these reactions.
- More Inclusive Marketing: Diverse faces in campaigns are now as important as the garments themselves.
- Street Style as Subversion: The vibrant streetwear documented during NYFW often outpaces the runways themselves for diversity and experimentation.
What’s Next? The Path Forward
If NYFW is to become truly representative, industry observers say change must move beyond individual shows and marketing slogans. Key steps include:
- Systematic inclusive hiring in model agencies
- Redefining beauty standards in sample sizing and garment construction
- Support for emerging designers from non-traditional or marginalized backgrounds
- Transparent reporting on casting and hiring practices
- Continued consumer pressure for change
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is NYFW more diverse than it was a decade ago?
A: Yes, NYFW has made progress, with more models of color and advocacy moments than in the past. However, critics say change is not as deep or consistent as needed, especially at high-profile shows.
Q: Does body inclusivity extend to all shows at NYFW?
A: No. While some independent designers regularly feature plus-size models, most major brands still cast only a handful of non-thin models, and sample sizes often exclude larger bodies.
Q: Who are “nepo babies,” and how do they affect NYFW?
A: “Nepo babies” (children of celebrities or industry insiders) are increasingly prominent at NYFW, both on runways and in prime audience seats, often raising concerns about access and meritocracy in the industry.
Q: How are advocacy and social causes incorporated into NYFW?
A: Through partnerships with nonprofits, shows highlighting causes (like pet adoption or disease research), and some designers using their platforms for activism.
Q: What major trends defined NYFW 2025?
A: Key trends included bright pinks and reds, polka dots, expressive accessories, and a return to both maximalism and minimalism in silhouettes. Street style continued to embody New York’s multicultural identity, even as the runways themselves lagged in full representation.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
