Home » Beauty

Maybelline Sky High Mascara: Prime Day’s Viral Lash Sensation Reviewed

Everything you need to know about Maybelline Sky High Mascara—from viral hype to Prime Day savings, real-life results, and expert-backed reasons it's a cult classic.

By Medha deb

Created on Sep 30, 2025

If you were searching for the most raved-about drugstore mascara—the one dominating TikTok, earning beauty editor love, and now slashed in price for Prime Day—you’ve landed in the right place. Below, you’ll find a comprehensive review of Maybelline’s New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara: what makes it iconic, its real-world performance, and the secrets behind its viral status and unbeatable value.

About Maybelline Sky High Mascara

The Maybelline Sky High Mascara landed with a bang, instantly finding cult status across drugstore beauty fans and professional makeup artists alike. It promises—by all accounts—to deliver unlimited length and volume, no matter your lash type. But what’s truly behind the hype, especially now that it’s even more tempting with Prime Day deals?

Type: Volumizing & lengthening mascara
Formula features: Infused with bamboo extract and lengthening fibers
Brush design: Slim, flexible plastic wand—slightly tapered to ensure thorough application
Price: Regularly about $12, but less than $8 during Prime Day sale
Variants: Multiple black shades, plus brown, navy, burgundy, shimmers, and waterproof

This mascara has gone from drugstore basic to a fully-fledged range, inspiring serums and tinted options owing to its roaring popularity. Celebrities—and their makeup artists—have publicly declared their allegiance to Sky High, cementing its must-have status on red carpets and in viral social media posts alike.

Prime Day Savings: Why Now’s the Best Time to Buy

Prime Day offers a unique chance to pick up Sky High at a price that’s rarely matched—54% off in the UK and less than $8 in the US. That’s less than the cost of a takeaway latte or glossy magazine for a tube that will last almost three months, even with daily use. Every single color and the waterproof version is included in the deal, so it’s a great time to stock up or try a new shade without commitment.

Amazon Prime Day Price: Typically under $8 (down from $12+)
Applicability: All shades—including limited editions—are part of the sale

With mascara being a staple that should be refreshed every 3–4 months for eye safety, it’s never a bad idea to buy a backup when it’s on sale.

The Formula and Wand: How Sky High Delivers Drama

What distinguishes Sky High from a sea of drugstore competitors? It’s all in the formula and brush pairing, which seems simple but is engineered for maximum effect. Here’s why beauty editors—and your Instagram feed—can’t stop raving about it:

Bamboo Extract & Fibers: The star ingredients not only lengthen but help strengthen lashes, giving each hair subtle structure and volume with every coat.
Clump-Resistant: The combination of the formula and brush delivers multiple coats without the dreaded thick, lumpy effect—even if you love to layer for extra drama.
Staying Power: Sky High doesn’t transfer, flake, or leave “panda eyes.” Expect budge-proof wear through work, sweat, tears, and even swimming (with the waterproof version).

The Unique Brush

The brush deserves its own spotlight. Made of flexible, high-quality plastic, it achieves a balance between:

Length: Long enough to coat every lash in one sweep
Precision: Slightly tapered tip means you can target shorter inner and outer lashes easily
Flexibility: Allows you to wiggle and grab even the smallest lashes without poking skin or causing messes

Shades Galore: Which Sky High Mascara Suits You?

While classic black is always in demand, Maybelline has made Sky High available in options ranging from subtle to statement:

Cosmic Black: Deepest jet black for maximum drama
Brown: Softer, natural-looking finish for everyday wear
Navy Blue, Burgundy, and Shimmer: Trendy shades for those wanting a pop of color or something festive

To top it off, the waterproof version is identical in formula and performance, offering smudge-proof, cry-proof wear in all colors. This allows for creative expression without sacrificing longevity or lash health.

Real-Life Application: Endurance and Results

Drugstore mascaras have a reputation for being either too wet (prone to smudging) or too dry (flaky with wear). Maybelline Sky High strikes an ideal middle ground:

Immediate Lift: One coat visibly lengthens and curls lashes, separating them cleanly
Buildable Drama: Add a second or third coat for genuinely dramatic, almost false-lash effect—no clumping
Endurance: Lasts for up to 12 hours, resisting humidity, sweat, and accidental eye-rubbing
Easy Removal: Washable versions come off with just water or mild cleanser; waterproof requires a gentle eye makeup remover

Aspect	Sky High Mascara	Typical Drugstore Mascara
Wand Design	Slim, flexible, tapered plastic	Often bristle or oversized rubber
Formula Base	Bamboo extract + tiny fibers	Standard wax and pigment base
Clump Factor	Low—even with layered coats	Varies; often clumps with layering
Smudge/Flake	Virtually none—not even after hours	Variable—often some transfer or flake
Shade Options	Multiple (black, brown, navy, burgundy, shimmer)	Limited (mostly black or brown)
Price (Prime Day)	$8 or less	$8–$15 for similar quality

Key Benefits of Maybelline Sky High Mascara

Affordable luxury: Delivers high-end lash drama at a drugstore price
Wide shade range: Try on-trend colors risk-free
Harsh-day proof: Stays intact through sweat, tears, rain, and long commutes
Lash care: Bamboo extract strengthens while fibers build volume
Beginner-friendly: Easy application and foolproof wand even for mascara novices
Editor-approved: Routinely praised and repurchased by industry experts—rare for a product that’s so affordable

Beauty Editor Insights: Who Sky High Is Best For

Experienced reviewers and beauty editors emphasize Sky High’s versatility. If you match any of these profiles, you’ll likely love it:

Short, straight, or hard-to-lift lashes: The formula and wand combo deliver visible lift that holds
Contact-lens wearers or sensitive eyes: Fragrance-free and ophthalmologist tested
Busy routines: Wears all day without maintenance or touch-up
Makeup minimalists: Brown and navy shades provide a softer, more natural effect; build up for more drama

How to Apply Sky High Mascara Like a Pro

Start at the base: Position the wand at the root of lashes and wiggle slightly upwards to separate and coat every lash
Use the tip: For inner and outer corners, employ the tapered end for precision
Layer to taste: Allow the first coat to set for a few seconds before applying more for major volume
Try a lash curler: For super-straight lashes, curl first for maximum lift
Remove gently: Use oil-based remover for waterproof; warm water and mild cleanser for washable formula

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: How often should I replace my Sky High Mascara?

A: Like most mascaras, for eye safety and optimal performance, replace your tube every 3–4 months even if there’s some left.

Q: Will it smudge or flake during the day?

A: No—Sky High’s formula is specifically designed to resist smudging, flaking, and transferring even after hours of wear.

Q: Is it safe for sensitive eyes?

A: Yes, it’s tested by ophthalmologists, suitable for contact lens wearers, and fragrance-free.

Q: Which color should I choose?

A: For the boldest look, go with Cosmic Black; for a natural finish, pick brown or navy; shimmer adds a fun, festive touch.

Q: What’s the difference between washable and waterproof versions?

A: Washable Sky High removes easily with water, while waterproof formulas require a makeup remover but last through swimming, sweat, and tears.

Why Maybelline Sky High Mascara Is Still Worth the Hype

If you’re seeking a mascara that lives up to viral status, has real expert backing, and delivers measurable results for less than a fancy lunch, Sky High is a clear winner. Between its Prime Day pricing, genuinely innovative formula, and the flexibility to suit casual or dramatic looks, it stands as a modern classic in the beauty world. Stock up before the sale ends, or try a new color for your next event—you may just find your new daily essential.

References

Author

medha deb

Medha Deb is an editor with a master's degree in Applied Linguistics from the University of Hyderabad. She believes that her qualification has helped her develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts.

Read full bio of medha deb