Makeup, Dating Apps, and Authenticity: What Actually Gets You Matches?
How realness, beauty choices, and personal style impact your dating app success, according to firsthand experience and expert advice.
Dating apps have become the modern playground for love, flirtation, and first impressions. But in this fast-paced, image-dominated landscape, how much does what’s on your face really matter? If you’ve ever agonized over whether to opt for a bold eye or a bare face in your profile photo, you’re not alone. This article dives into the nuanced relationship between makeup choices and dating app success, informed by firsthand experiment, expert insights, and practical recommendations for presenting your truest self while still celebrating your love for beauty.
An Eight-Year Single Streak and a Bold Experiment
The story begins with a candid confession: eight years single and a growing suspicion that makeup—specifically, a love of bold, statement looks—might be a factor. While makeup is a form of self-expression, on dating apps it can spark conflicting responses.
In a moment of curiosity (and, admittedly, frustration), the author decided to overhaul her dating app profile. She swapped all the carefully curated, makeup-heavy selfies for fresh, minimal or even no-makeup shots. The next day brought a surprise: quadruple the matches overnight compared to the usual rate. But with the surprise came mixed emotions, raising a critical question:
- Why did reduced makeup lead to more attention from potential matches?
- Is giving up a part of your identity necessary to attract a wider audience?
Why Does Less Makeup Get More Matches?
To make sense of the dramatic uptick in likes, two relationship and dating experts weighed in.
Perspective from Matchmaking and Therapy Professionals
Erika Kaplan, dating coach at Three Day Rule, noted that the result wasn’t shocking. On dating apps, presenting as genuine and relatable is paramount for many users. She explains that a full face of makeup is often viewed not as artistry or self-expression, but as a method of hiding one’s real self—even if that’s not the wearer’s intention.
Jennifer Silvershein Teplin, relationship therapist, added another layer: While a full makeup look might earn social compliments, it’s often misconstrued as inauthentic or “fake” in a dating context. She explains:
- Makeup is sometimes perceived as a “mask” akin to catfishing, which is a top fear among online daters.
- This skepticism applies across genders; both men and women tend to swipe left on heavy makeup, regardless of their real-world appreciation for artistry.
For women who enjoy beauty and fashion, this perception can be frustrating and contradictory. In-person, makeup might invite admiration from friends and strangers alike. But on dating platforms where trust and authenticity are at a premium, it risks being viewed with suspicion.
What others are reading
Online Dating’s Paradox: The Fear of Being Duped
Why is the reaction to makeup so sharply different on dating apps versus in real life? Much of it comes down to the fear of misrepresentation. Online daters want to ensure that the person they’ll meet matches the image on their profile. Any possibility of “bait and switch”—no matter how innocuous—can undermine potential connections.
Moreover:
- Dating apps leave little space for nuance; users have seconds to form impressions.
- Full-on glam can be interpreted as “trying too hard” or even insecurity, regardless of intention.
Yet, expecting everyone to present themselves plainly—or to conform to the minimal “no-makeup makeup” look—means erasing aspects of personality and creative passion, especially for beauty enthusiasts.
Reconciling Authenticity and Self-Expression
The key challenge becomes: How do you present your most authentic self without scaring away matches who crave “realness”?
Expert Advice: Tell a Story With Your Photos
Erika Kaplan recommends using photos that tell a story about your life, your interests, and your joys. Rather than a parade of selfies, consider:
- Photos of you doing things you love (crafting, hiking, traveling, at a concert, at a beauty event)
- Images with friends or family to highlight your relationships and social energy
- Snapshots that capture your happiest, most comfortable self—whether rocking a full face or fresh-faced
This strategy lets you showcase your multidimensional self. If makeup is part of your identity, you can highlight it contextually: as part of your career, your creative outlet, or your social experiences, rather than simply as an aesthetic shield.
Redefining Her Profile: A Balanced, Multifaceted Approach
After the experiment, the author refused to abandon makeup—a passion and a professional asset—for the sake of algorithmic approval. Here’s how she reworked her dating presence:
- Included a range of beauty looks: Both pared-down neutral styles (simple eyes, a glossy lip) and more dramatic, event-inspired glamour.
- Incorporated personality-driven images: For example, showcasing a bold, all-pink outfit on a Miami trip, a dynamic headshot at work, and a Fashion Week selfie.
- Added non-makeup-centric photos: Highlighting other aspects of life and interests—because, after all, real connection goes beyond lips and lashes.
This collage of images presents a fuller, more honest depiction: makeup lover, creative professional, and someone with a life rich in experiences. It signals genuine confidence without pretending to be barefaced or shying away from favorite beauty looks.
The Results: Did It Work?
The revamped profile delivered encouraging results. Instead of fewer matches, there was a notable increase in first dates—a sharper uptick than in previous years. The best part? There was no need to forgo the shimmer, gloss, or the satisfaction that comes from a perfected cat eye. Self-assurance and authenticity proved a compelling combo.
Product Recommendations: Makeup That Sparked Interest
For those interested in the details, the following products featured in the profile garnered positive attention and real-life interest. These are the staples that both perform well IRL and photograph beautifully for online profiles:
- Sunnies Face Lip Treat: Comfortable, subtly glossy tint for effortless lip color.
- Kjaer Weis The Beautiful Tint: Lightweight, skin-loving—all about that healthy sheen without heavy coverage.
- Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara: Defines lashes without clumping or flaking, perfect for a range of looks from understated to glam.
- YSL Beauty Nu Lip and Cheek Balmy Tint: Versatile and blendable, delivers a natural flush on lips and cheeks.
These products exemplify the happy medium: they enhance features, reflect artistry, and keep the overall effect approachable and trustworthy.
Expert-Endorsed Tips: Curating the Perfect Dating App Profile
- Balance Your Images: Include a mix of close-ups, candid shots, activity photos, and varied makeup looks.
- Lead With Yourself, Not Just Your Face: Let your photos and bio reflect what brings you joy, your values, and your lifestyle—not just your favorite liner.
- Be Upfront About Your Identity: If makeup is a big part of your life or career, mention it! Honesty attracts compatible connections.
- Embrace Originality: Don’t feel pressured to fit the “natural only” mold. The right match will appreciate what makes you unique—including your beauty style.
- Keep It Current: Use recent photos that reflect how you look most days—not just special occasions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is less makeup always better on dating apps?
A: Not universally. While minimal makeup can signal “authenticity” to some users, the most important factor is that your appearance matches your real-life identity. Consistency and honesty matter more than strict minimalism.
Q: How can I express my love of makeup without scaring off potential matches?
A: Incorporate photos that show makeup in the context of your interests and personality, like images from beauty events, or outfits that reflect your aesthetic. Use a mix of beauty and lifestyle photos for balance.
Q: Why do some people react negatively to makeup-heavy photos?
A: The main reason is the fear of being misled, as heavy makeup is sometimes perceived as a mask. However, context and presentation matter—a cohesive, honest profile can overcome this bias.
Q: Should I hide my creative side to get more matches?
A: No. You’re more likely to attract matches who appreciate and connect with your genuine self if you lean into what makes you happy—including your creativity and love for beauty.
Q: What makeup products work best for dating app profile photos?
A: Soft, radiant products that enhance your natural features, like lightweight skin tints, balmy lip colors, and separating mascaras, tend to photograph well and adapt to different lighting conditions.
Striking the Right Balance: Your Makeup, Your Rules
The story of navigating makeup and dating apps is ultimately a narrative about self-discovery, boundaries, and the importance of self-assurance in digital dating. The lesson isn’t that everyone should abandon bold makeup or embrace a no-makeup look to gain more matches. Rather, it’s about:
- Being mindful of first impressions while preserving genuine self-expression
- Understanding that the right matches will resonate with your whole self—not just a carefully filtered version
- Remembering that online dating is an opportunity to curate your story—complete with all the facets that make you uniquely lovable
So whether your signature is a radiant blue eye shadow or a just-bitten lip balm, what matters most is that your profile tells your story. The world of online dating may reward “authenticity,” but there’s no reason that authenticity can’t include a bold cat eye, a dewy cheek, or the artistry of a perfectly executed makeup look. Who knows? The next match might be swiping right not in spite of your style, but because you dared to share it.
Beth Gillette is the beauty editor at Cosmopolitan, covering skincare, makeup, hair, nails, and all things beauty. She brings years of expertise to her coverage, with a special passion for helping readers find confidence in self-expression—on and off the apps.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
