Kylie Jenner Kyshadow vs. Shaaanxo: The Ultimate Eyeshadow Palette Showdown
Two cult-favorite palettes go head-to-head to reveal the differences, similarities, and best buys for makeup lovers everywhere.
Kylie Jenner Kyshadow vs. Shaaanxo Palette: Which Should You Buy?
When Kylie Jenner announced her new makeup launch, fans flocked to buy the first-ever Kyshadow palette, dubbed The Bronze Palette. Its release sparked intense discussion in the beauty world — some swore it was eerily similar to the Shaaanxo Palette by beauty blogger Shannon Harris (Shaaanxo) with BH Cosmetics. Are these two palettes twins, or does each offer something unique for makeup lovers? We break down the differences, similarities, and key buying factors in this exhaustive comparison.
Contents
- Packaging
- Shadow Shades & Finishes
- Quality & Performance
- Price & Value
- Comparison Table: Kyshadow vs. Shaaanxo
- Final Thoughts – Who Should Buy Which?
- FAQs
Packaging
First impressions matter — and both palettes deliver a sleek, travel-friendly design, but there are notable differences:
- Kyshadow Palette: Square-shaped, measuring approximately 4.25 inches in length and width. The individual eyeshadow pans are slightly smaller, about a quarter inch less in diameter than those in Shaaanxo’s palette. It features a magnetic closure, and the pans are removable — ideal for customizing or swapping shades if you own more Kylie singles. There’s no mirror or bonus compartment within.
- Shaaanxo Palette: Larger at 5 inches per side and includes larger pans. One practical feature is the built-in mirror on the inside of the lid. Uniquely, flip it over and you’ll find a hidden second palette — nine coordinating lip colors, which massively increases utility for travel or touch-ups. Shadows are glued in place and not refillable.
Packaging verdict: If portability and customization matter, Kyshadow wins; if you want added value and function, Shaaanxo is the clear winner.
Shadow Shades & Finishes
At first glance, the shade layouts seem nearly identical. Both palettes feature nine pans arranged in a grid offering a blend of matte, bronze, orange, and cream tones for classic smokey eyes or warm sunset looks.
Direct Shade Comparisons
- Both offer a matte cream in the top left and a deep brown or black in the bottom right for contrast and definition.
- The central shades feature a range of tawny oranges, peachy browns, and bronzes.
Side-by-side swatches reveal subtle but real differences:
- Kyshadow: Leans matte — six out of nine shades have a matte finish. The shades are generally warm-toned, with strong bronze and orange influences (think: Kylie’s signature eye looks).
- Shaaanxo: Offers more shimmer and satin. Shaaanxo’s palette stands out with its glimmering bronze and taupe shades, making it a better choice for those who prefer luminous, metallic eyes.
Overall, only four of the nine shades can be called dupes — indistinguishable in color and finish. The remaining tones look similar in the pan but differ on the skin due to finish, undertone, and depth.
| Shade | Kyshadow (Kylie) | Shaaanxo (BH Cosmetics) | Finish Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cream/Vanilla | Matte | Matte | Identical |
| Mid Bronze | Matte | Shimmer | Kyshadow is flatter, Shaaanxo has glow |
| Peach/Orange | Vivid matte orange | Satin peach | Different undertone |
| Deep Brown/Black | Intense matte brown-black | Soft matte brown | Kyshadow is richer, Shaaanxo is more muted |
| Bronze/Taupe | Warm matte | Metallic shimmer | Shaaanxo is glossier |
Swatching Experience:
- Kyshadow: Some shades require multiple swipes for even pigmentation.
- Shaaanxo: Shades are creamier and swatch more smoothly and evenly, especially shimmer tones.
Quality & Performance
Both palettes score high marks for blendability and smooth application, but distinct nuances appear in direct testing:
- Kyshadow: The matte shades are slightly more pigmented, allowing for dramatic, editorial looks with fewer layers. Ideal for sharp cut creases and bold gradient eyes.
- Shaaanxo: The shimmer and satin shades offer a silky, creamy feel. These colors glide on effortlessly, particularly beneficial for beginners or anyone who struggles with patchiness. The finish is softer and more forgiving.
Longevity:
- Kyshadow: Promoted as long-wearing, but a primer is recommended for best results — especially on oily lids.
- Shaaanxo: Also long-wearing but may fade slightly faster if not paired with a primer due to the creamy texture.
Real-world testers comment that both palettes are suitable for all-day wear and neither have excessive fallout. Shaaanxo’s formula is marginally easier to blend, but Kyshadow wins for matte color payoff.
Price & Value
| Palette | Number of Eye Shadows | Extra Features | Price (USD) | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kyshadow | 9 | Removable pans | $42 | Frequently sold out |
| Shaaanxo | 9 | Mirror & 9 lip colors | $15 (sale price; originally $22) | Readily available online |
Value verdict: For the price-conscious, Shaaanxo offers the best value — nearly a third of Kyshadow’s price, plus nine lip colors and a mirror for one affordable package. Kyshadow offers brand prestige and customization but at a premium, and is often difficult to purchase due to high demand and limited releases.
Comparison Table: Kyshadow vs. Shaaanxo
| Feature | Kylie Kyshadow | Shaaanxo Palette |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Matte, warm, minimal, Instagram-chic | Shimmery, versatile, value packed |
| Finish variety | Matte focus | Satin & shimmer |
| Packaging extras | Removable pans | Mirror, lip palette |
| Best for… | Matte lovers, Kylie fans, artists | Shimmer fans, budget shoppers |
| Price | $$$ | $ |
| Availability | Limited/sold out | Widely available |
Final Thoughts – Who Should Buy Which?
Are the Kyshadow and Shaaanxo palettes twins or sisters? Beauty insiders agree: these palettes are extremely similar in layout and color story, with only slight distinctions in finish and undertone across most shades. In the end, the choice is less about duplication and more about preference and budget:
- If you want matte shadows, brand prestige, and Instagram style: Go for Kyshadow. Its name and color payoff carry a certain cult status, ideal for those who collect Kylie Cosmetics or crave precise editorial looks.
- If you want shimmer variety, added lip shades, and best value for money: Shaaanxo delivers unbeatable functionality. The quality of shimmer and finish is praised as creamier and smoother in many tests.
- If you are a beginner or on a budget: Shaaanxo makes luxury looks accessible at a lower cost — excellent for students, new makeup fans, or anyone trying out warm-toned smokey eyes.
In conclusion: Both palettes are popular for good reason. Neither is a complete dupe or direct copy, but the similarities are more than enough that choosing between the two comes down to price, preference for finish, and brand loyalty.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Are Kyshadow and Shaaanxo palettes exactly the same?
A: No, there are similarities in the shade selection and layout, but key differences exist in finish, packaging, and some undertones. Only four shades can be considered true dupes.
Q: Which palette is more pigmented?
A: Kyshadow’s matte shades are generally slightly more pigmented, while Shaaanxo’s shimmers are smoother and creamier. Both palettes have good blendability.
Q: Which palette is better for beginners?
A: Shaaanxo’s creamier formula and shimmer finishes make blending easier for beginners, while Kyshadow’s mattes are better for advanced techniques.
Q: Is Shaaanxo palette a true dupe for Kyshadow?
A: Not a perfect dupe — about four shades are nearly identical, but the rest differ in finish and color depth. Shaaanxo offers additional lip shades for more versatility.
Q: Are the palettes worth the hype?
A: Both palettes are well-rated for quality. Kyshadow appeals to Kylie fans and matte lovers, while Shaaanxo suits those wanting more shimmer and multi-use options for a lower price.
Q: Why is Kyshadow often sold out?
A: High demand, limited releases, and Kylie’s massive fanbase cause the Kyshadow palette to sell out quickly whenever restocked.
Q: Is Kylie’s palette customizable?
A: Yes, Kyshadow’s pans are removable for easy swapping if you buy individual Kylie shadows. Shaaanxo’s palette is fixed and not refillable.
Q: How do prices compare?
A: Kyshadow retails for $42 (often resold for higher when sold out). Shaaanxo is regularly available for $15-$22 and includes nine lip shades.
Beauty Community: Social Reaction
The similarity sparked debate on social media after Shaaanxo shared her thoughts and fans posted side-by-side photos for comparison. Some labeled it a copycat move, while Kylie’s followers argued the bronze palette is a classic look with limited creative variation. The consensus? Both palettes earn their place in the beauty world, and both offer a solid warm-toned selection for those wanting a versatile eyeshadow kit.
Written by Brooke Shunatona, contributing writer for Cosmopolitan.com.
References
- https://www.cosmopolitan.com/style-beauty/beauty/a62223/kylie-jenner-kyshadow-palette-compared-to-shaaanxo/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjbh9BnWv_A
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hrw9jf9W7lU
- https://www.unitedbypop.com/lifestyle/are-kylie-jenner-and-shaaanxos-eyeshadow-palettes-just-a-little-too-similar/
Similar Articles
Read full bio of medha deb
