24 Best Mary Jane Shoes for Every Style in 2023
Discover the top 24 Mary Jane shoes that blend timeless charm, modern style, and all-day comfort for every fall occasion.
The 24 Best Mary Jane Shoes for Every Fall Outfit in 2023
Mary Janes—those enduring icons of fashion—have made another stylish comeback. With their closed-toe silhouette, signature strap across the instep, and myriad of materials, the best Mary Jane shoes straddle the line between timeless classic and fashion-forward. Whether you’re seeking a pair for the office, a night out, or just to elevate your day-to-day look, Mary Janes deliver on both comfort and versatility.
We’ve meticulously rounded up 24 of the best Mary Jane shoes of 2023, featuring everything from luxurious platforms and plush flats to eco-friendly knits and edgy leathers. Dive in to discover pairs that suit every taste, mood, and budget this fall.
Why Mary Janes Are Having Their Biggest Moment Yet
- Versatility: Mary Janes seamlessly shift between casual and dressy looks.
- Comfort: Most come with a stable heel, cushioned sole, or memory-foam footbed.
- Timelessness: The silhouette has continued relevance, echoing both vintage charm and current trends.
- Variety: From Y2K-inspired platforms to ballet flats, there’s a Mary Jane for every wardrobe.
Top 24 Mary Jane Shoes of 2023
1. J.Crew Millie Mary Jane Heels (Satin & Leather)
With an elegantly capped-toe design and dazzling rhinestone buckles, these Mary Jane heels are the ultimate dance-floor companions. Available in both satin and leather, they offer sizes 5-12, and shine brightest at celebrations, weddings, or stylish workdays. Color: Black.
2. Nodaleto Bulla Babies Denim Platform Mary Jane Pumps
For those willing to splurge, these denim platform pumps stand out with their exaggerated heel and playful attitude. The bold design comes in indigo, red, pink, and shimmering silver. Sizes: IT35-41.
- Sturdy platform sole for extra height
- Perfect for making a statement at events
3. Larroude Olivia Platform Pump in Black Patent Leather
Named for Gen Z icon Olivia Rodrigo, this Y2K-inspired silhouette aims high. The luxurious memory-foam cushioning ensures comfort, and the glossy patent finish is pure drama. Color: Black (cream is often sold out). Sizes: 5-11.
4. Sandy Liang Mary Jane Pointe in Brunette Satin
Chic, ballerina-inspired, and ready to strut, the Sandy Liang Mary Jane Pointe boasts an adjustable strap and plush padded leather footbed. Sizes: 35-39. Color: Satin Brown.
5. MARNI Leather Mary Jane Platform Pumps
What others are reading
MARNI reinvents the Mary Jane with unexpected soles, contrasting hues, dainty bows, and a polished gold buckle. A designer splurge that guarantees double-takes. Sizes: IT36-41. Color: Black.
6. Ollio Faux Suede Casual Mary Jane Ballet Flats
These delicate-heeled Mary Janes come in ten vivid shades—from mustard yellow to lilac—so you can match or contrast every fall outfit. The slip-on style is loved for its class and comfort. Sizes: 6-11.
- Highly affordable
- Easy to dress up or down
- Great user reviews for fit and softness
7. Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane
Eco-conscious fashionistas, meet the Mary Jane made from recycled water bottles. Rothy’s soft-knit material molds to your foot, and the elastic strap stretches perfectly for comfort. Sizes: 5-13. Multiple colors including Black and Sandy Cat.
- Machine-washable
- Lightweight and cushy, suitable for all-day wear
8. Dr. Martens Polley Smooth Leather Mary Janes
A cult favorite among T-strap styles, Dr. Martens’ take is as iconic as their boots: smooth leather, substantial sole, and rugged yet versatile flair. Sizes: 36-43. Color: Black.
- Over 400 rave reviews for durability
- Surprisingly comfortable after break-in
9. Madewell The Elsie Mary Jane Flat
Suede elegance meets pointed toes in this subtly modern update. Mahogany, timeless black, and ember offer options for every preference. Pairs perfectly with cropped denim and slouchy knitwear for early fall chic.
10. Madden Girl Women’s Tutu Ballet Flat
A patent-finish, short-heeled classic at an unbeatable price. Boldly offered in red, silver, blush, brown, and black, this Mary Jane is a vintage callback you can wear every day.
11. Old Navy Mary Jane Square-Toe Ballet Flats
Old Navy brings a classic silhouette with an elastic strap for ultra-comfortable, all-day wear. The blush pink draws early fall attention and feels endlessly wearable.
12. Coach Angelina Mary Jane
Known for its rebrand and modern classics, Coach launches a striking heel with signature buttons. The unique shape and choice of ruby, black, or white keep your evening and office looks on-trend.
13. J.Crew Factory Mary Jane Flats
Elevate your wardrobe with J.Crew Factory’s burgundy flats, gold hardware, and luxe appearance. Also available in silver croc and plain black, these shoes feel twice as expensive as their price.
14. Sézane Elodie Mary Janes
For those who crave Parisian flair, the Elodie features three adjustable straps, gold-finish buckles, leather lining, and a just-right 2-inch heel. Available in black, garden green, taupe, and more.
15-24. More Mary Jane Favorites for 2023
- Sam Edelman Michaela Mary Jane Flats: Timeless black leather, slightly pointed toe. Professional and elegant.
- Naturalizer Maxwell Mary Janes: Memory foam insoles and simple lines for ultimate comfort.
- Aquazzura Bow Tie 105 Mary Jane Pumps: High style, luxury finish, bold pointed toe.
- Charles & Keith Platform Mary Janes: Chunky sole, fashion-forward affordability.
- Katy Perry The Geli Mary Jane Jelly Flats: Fun, playful, waterproof, perfect for rainy-day styling.
- Reformation Bethany Block Heel Mary Jane: Sustainable materials meet on-trend square heels.
- Steve Madden Besa Mary Jane Pumps: Edgy, chunky heel, classic with a twist.
- Vagabond Shoemakers Delia Mary Janes: Sleek, understated, European-inspired design.
- Bella Belle Florence Embellished Mary Janes: Romance, beadwork, evening elegance.
- Belle by Sigerson Morrison Prue Mary Jane: Luxe suede, subtle heel, perfect day-to-night.
How to Style Mary Janes in 2023
- With cropped denim: Flat or low-heeled Mary Janes add Parisian flair to casual outfits.
- For office chic: Try pointed-toe or platform Mary Janes with tailored trousers.
- Evenings out: Satin or patent-leather Mary Janes with a midi dress create elevated elegance fast.
- With socks or tights: Add contrast using patterned socks or sheer tights for a playful, on-trend look.
- Layer with cozy knits: Mary Janes pair well with slouchy sweaters and pleated skirts for early fall or transitional weather.
Mary Jane Shoes: A Style Guide
| Mary Jane Style | Best For | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Classic Flat | Everyday, Office | Slip-on, low profile, comfortable strap |
| Platform | Fashion Statements, Nights Out | Chunky sole, bold heel, often Y2K-inspired |
| Dressy/Heels | Parties, Formal Events | Satin/leather materials, embellished buckles |
| Ballet Style | Casual, Feminine Looks | Delicate sole, often pastel or neutral hues |
| Eco-Friendly | Conscious Buyers, Travel | Knit/recycled materials, washable, lightweight |
| Chunky/Edgy | Trendy, Streetwear | Thick sole, contrast details (Dr. Martens) |
Frequently Asked Questions About Mary Jane Shoes
Q: Are Mary Jane shoes in style for 2023?
A: Yes. Runway designers and street style stars are bringing Mary Janes back in new platforms, materials, and colors, making them one of the most sought-after shoes for fall and winter 2023.
Q: Can Mary Janes be dressed up or down?
A: Absolutely. They work as well with jeans and sweaters for day looks as they do with slip dresses or tailoring for evening, proving incredibly versatile across events and seasons.
Q: What socks or tights should I wear with Mary Janes?
A: Try sheer socks, ribbed crew socks, or thick tights. Patterned or colored socks can add playful contrast; opaque tights offer warmth for fall while keeping your look polished.
Q: Are Mary Janes comfortable for all-day wear?
A: Most Mary Janes are designed with comfort in mind, featuring padded insoles and arch support. Flats and block heels tend to be comfier for longer wear, while sky-high platforms are best for special occasions.
Q: How can I care for my Mary Jane shoes?
A: Store in a cool, dry place, wipe down regularly with a soft cloth, and use appropriate cleaners based on the shoe’s material (leather, suede, canvas, or synthetics). Invest in quality inserts for extra support.
Final Thoughts: Why Mary Janes Are the Ultimate Fall Shoe
From their playful roots to their current must-have status, Mary Janes bring a sense of youthful nostalgia and modern luxury to every step. Whether you reach for a bold platform, a polished flat, or a vintage-inspired heel, you’ll find that this silhouette is both a conversation starter and a wardrobe workhorse—a trend worth investing in this season and beyond.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
