The Best Eyeliners for Every Look, Tested by Beauty Experts
From classic pencils to cutting-edge liquids, discover the highest-rated eyeliners for every style, need, and skill level.
Whether you favor a smudged out smoky eye, sleek cat flick, playful color, or water-resistant lines, finding the best eyeliner is fundamental to achieving standout eye makeup looks. With formulas evolving rapidly, the best options today combine bold pigment, smooth application, and lasting power—from classic drugstore pencils to ultra-precise luxury liquids. This comprehensive guide explores top picks for every category, insider tips from beauty pros, and answers to your most common eyeliner questions.
What to Look for in an Eyeliner
Choosing the right eyeliner comes down to more than color or price. Here are the top criteria to keep in mind:
- Formula: Gel, pencil, liquid, cream, or felt-tip—each delivers a unique look and suits different skill levels.
- Longevity: Waterproof and smudge-proof options ensure lines last through humidity, sweat, and long wear.
- Application: Twist-up, sharpenable, brush, or pen applicators can impact ease and precision.
- Finish: Matte, satin, shimmer, or metallic for customizing your style.
- Shade Selection: Neutrals, bold colors, and skin tone inclusivity let you express your look.
The Top Eyeliners, By Category
Based on extensive testing and expert feedback, these are the standout eyeliners across every format and use case.
Best Overall: Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
This cult-favorite pen delivers intense pigment, an easy-glide felt tip, and a formula that holds from morning to night—without smudging or flaking. Ideal for both rookie and seasoned users, the tip allows everything from razor-sharp wings to subtle definition. It dries down quickly, resists sweat and tears, and comes in classic shades like black and brown as well as playful hues for added flair.
- Format: Liquid pen
- Wear time: Up to 12 hours
- Best for: Cat-eyes, tightlining, and watery eyelids
Best Drugstore Eyeliner: NYX Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
Proof you don’t need to spend a lot for bold, precise lines, NYX’s Epic Ink offers deeply saturated color with a flexible felt tip that makes flicks and curves effortless. Fans love its resemblance to luxury formulas at a budget price, along with shades suited for daily wear or all-out glam. The lightweight formula sets fast and holds steady, making it perfect for busy days or beginners mastering their technique.
- Format: Waterproof liquid pen
- Wear time: Up to 10 hours
- Best for: Defined wings, quick applications, daily use
Best Pencil Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
Beloved for its buttery smoothness, this creamy pencil offers maximum pigment and impressive blendability before it locks into place for all-day wear. The massive shade library covers signature blacks and browns, shimmering metallics, and vibrant pastels, making it a pro favorite for both classic and creative looks. Waterproof and fade-proof, it glides over lash lines and waterlines with zero tugging.
- Format: Pencil (needs sharpening)
- Wear time: Up to 16 hours
- Best for: Waterline, tightlining, smoky eyes, color play
Best Gel Eyeliner: Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil Eyeliner
This gel pencil rivals high-end formulas with its opaqueness, lasting grip, and versatility. The formula blends easily for smoky looks but quickly sets to a bulletproof finish—perfect for both waterline definition and crisp outer wings. With a range of matte and shimmer shades and a price that beats many competitors, it’s a toolbox must-have for makeup minimalists and maximalists alike.
- Format: Gel pencil
- Wear time: Up to 36 hours
- Best for: Waterline, sweaty days, smoky eyes
Best Luxury Eyeliner: Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal Liner
For ultimate glide and rich payoff, VB Beauty’s award-winning pencil pairs an ultra-soft gel formula with lush shades—including creamy neutrals and chic jewel tones. The texture smudges beautifully for a sultry effect, then stays put with minimal transfer. It’s especially popular among professionals for editorial moments and statement eyes.
What others are reading
- Format: Luxury gel pencil
- Wear time: 12+ hours
- Best for: Buildable looks, graphic lines, waterline
Best for Beginners: L’Oréal Paris Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner
If you struggle with shaky lines, this ultra-fine felt tip makes it easy to nail your first flick. The inky black formula glides smoothly without feathering, dries almost instantly, and is formulated to stay put even on oily eyelids. The pen-style packaging is lightweight and easy to control, meaning fewer mishaps and cleaner results for newbies.
- Format: Precision felt tip pen
- Wear time: Up to 12 hours
- Best for: Beginners, simple liner looks
Best for Sensitive Eyes: MAC Eye Kohl
Tested by ophthalmologists and suitable for contact lens wearers, MAC’s Eye Kohl is gentle on delicate eyes yet delivers saturated color in a formula that glides smoothly. It blends beautifully for a soft, smoky effect and comes in both classic blacks and pops of color. The creamy texture is easy to apply and remove, minimizing irritation.
- Format: Pencil kohl
- Wear time: Up to 12 hours
- Best for: Waterline, sensitivity, contact lens wearers
Best Waterproof Eyeliner: Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner
Favored in pro kits for tightlining and budge-proof lines, this ultra-compact gel formula offers intense color that wears for up to 16 hours. It’s particularly beloved for use on the upper waterline (tightlining) and for artistic runway looks that demand precise, resilient lines.
- Format: Gel/cream in pot
- Wear time: 16 hours
- Best for: Tightlining, long events, oily lids
Best for Waterline: Kulfi Underlined Kajal Waterproof Liner
This innovative, clean formula was designed specifically for the waterline—where smudging and irritation often spell disaster. It glides on gently, resists both oil and tears, and suits a wide array of skin tones, making it a go-to for well-defined inner rims and classic kohl effects.
- Format: Waterproof pencil kajal
- Wear time: Up to 12 hours
- Best for: Waterline, vibrant color, all skin tones
How to Choose and Apply Eyeliner Like a Pro
Picking your perfect eyeliner is only half the journey; mastering the method is equally key. Here are tips direct from professional makeup artists:
- Consider eye shape: Almond eyes suit most styles, but round eyes can be elongated with winged tips, while hooded lids benefit from a thinner line close to lashes.
- Layer for lasting power: Set pencil liners with matching eyeshadow to boost longevity and prevent transfer.
- Work in short strokes: Drawing liner in small, connected dashes along the lash line offers more control than a single sweep.
- Clean up mistakes: A cotton swab dipped in micellar water erases errors without ruining your base makeup.
- Try the reverse eyeliner trend: Flipping bold color or liner to the lower lash line is a fresh, runway-inspired look favored by celebrities and TikTok influencers.
Trending Eyeliner Looks for 2025
From runway to real life, these modern styles are dominating beauty pages and social feeds:
- Reverse Eyeliner: Applying a vivid or bold shade along the lower lash line rather than the top for a statement effect.
- Floating Crease Liner: Drawing a clean swipe above the natural crease for an eye-opening, graphic pop.
- Double Wing: Creating parallel wings on upper and lower lash lines for a dramatic, elongating finish.
- Softly Smoky Waterline: Using long-wear pencils blended out for a faded yet defined under-eye.
Tips for Every Skill Level
| Skill Level | Recommended Eyeliner | Pro Tips |
|---|---|---|
| Beginner | L’Oréal Paris Infallible Super Slim | Start with the outer corner and join short lines for steadiness. |
| Intermediate | Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil | Blend edges for softness before product sets; set with powder for extra hold. |
| Advanced | Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline, Stila Stay All Day | Try graphic shapes, colored liner, and tightlining for editorial looks. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Which eyeliner is best for the waterline?
Look for creamy, waterproof gel or kohl pencils. Fan favorites include Urban Decay 24/7, Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil, and Kulfi Underlined Kajal. These resist moisture and sebum, offering vibrant color that doesn’t fade or smudge throughout the day.
Can liquid eyeliner be used on the waterline?
It’s not recommended, as most liquid formulas can irritate delicate inner rims and are not designed to adhere or last in the waterline. Stick with waterproof pencils, gels, or specially formulated kajals for this area.
How do I keep my eyeliner from smudging?
- Opt for waterproof, long-wearing formulas.
- Prep lids with primer or a touch of translucent powder.
- Set pencil liner with a matching powder shadow.
What eyeliner is best for sensitive or allergy-prone eyes?
Choose ophthalmologist-tested pencils such as MAC Eye Kohl, and always remove makeup thoroughly with a gentle cleanser to minimize irritation.
How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?
Use an oil-based or dual-phase makeup remover designed for waterproof formulas. Soak a cotton pad and gently press to dissolve resistant pigment before wiping away.
Expert and Reader Reviews
- Readers rave about NYX Epic Ink for affordable, long-lasting definition that rivals luxury pens.
- Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil is described as a “game-changer” for anyone needing a budget-friendly pencil with pro-level performance.
- For luxe lovers, Victoria Beckham’s Satin Kajal is cited for its creamy, blendable texture and runway-worthy shades.
- MAC Eye Kohls get praise for being gentle, versatile, and safe for contact lens users.
Final Thoughts: How to Find Your Perfect Eyeliner
Your ideal eyeliner depends on your preferred look, skin type, skill level, and lifestyle. Whether you crave ultra-black intensity, easy-blend smudging, or bulletproof waterproofing, today’s top picks offer a solution for every eye shape and personality. Experiment with textures, finishes, and trending looks until you land on your signature line—and don’t be afraid to add a pop of color or graphic edge to update your routine.
Related Makeup Tips & Trends
- Explore the latest brow trends to complement your new eyeliner look.
- Check out tips for mascara layering to max out length and volume.
- Master the reverse eyeliner trend popularized on social media for a runway-inspired finish.
- See how to apply liner based on your unique eye shape for the most flattering results.
Shop Smarter: Eyeliner Buying Checklist
- Test for comfort—some formulas are gentler for sensitive eyes.
- Look for application hacks from beauty editors and makeup artists.
- Don’t fear color—rich blues, greens, and burgundies are in for 2025.
- Stock up on both pencil and liquid to switch from day to night.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of medha deb
