The Best Eyeliners for Older Women: Top Picks and Expert Advice (2024)
Discover the ideal eyeliners for mature skin, top expert picks, and age-friendly tips to enhance and define your eyes beautifully.
Finding the perfect eyeliner for mature skin can make a world of difference, from enhancing eye shape to adding vibrancy and definition. As skin changes with age—becoming drier, more delicate, and prone to fine lines—the right eyeliner must offer smooth application, gentle formulas, and lasting performance. This comprehensive guide features the best eyeliners for older women in 2024, plus expert buying advice, real-user feedback, and answers to the most common liner questions so you can confidently achieve beautiful, defined eyes at any age.
Why Choosing the Right Eyeliner for Mature Eyes Matters
As we age, our eyelids often become thinner, more sensitive, and sometimes hooded. The right eyeliner can:
- Add definition without harshness
- Glide smoothly over delicate skin with minimal tugging
- Stay put all day and resist smudging, even on watery or oily lids
- Enhance confidence and make eyes appear brighter and more awake
Our Top Eyeliner Picks for Older Women in 2024
Each of the following eyeliners was chosen based on formula, ease of use, staying power, color selection, and performance on mature skin. Product testimonials and expert insights guarantee solutions for every style and concern.
1. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
- Formula: Creamy pencil with jojoba oil and vitamin E for added nourishment
- Shade range: 30 versatile colors
- Key benefits: Glides on smoothly, waterproof, high pigmentation, suitable for sensitive eyes
What reviewers say: “Urban Decay is the only liner that glides on effortlessly. Regular pencil liners skip on my eyelid, but this makes it easy to create a fine line or smudge for softness.”
Cons: Some users find it difficult to sharpen the pencil.
2. KISS New York Luxury Eyeliner
- Formula: Cream, twist-up design (no sharpener needed)
- Shade range: 2 classic colors
- Key benefits: Long-wearing, easy to use, budget-friendly
Pro Tip: Use an angled brush to apply this liner as a soft, stamped powder for clients with shaking hands or difficulty drawing a straight line.
What reviewers say: “I’ve used this eyeliner for 15 years; it always works well and stays put.”
Cons: Some users note minor smudging on very oily lids.
3. Laura Geller INKcredible Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil
- Formula: Waterproof creamy gel
- Shade range: Multiple, including black and navy
- Key benefits: Long-lasting, doesn’t transfer on hooded or creased lids, highly pigmented
Makeup Pro Tip: “Lining the eyes—especially the upper lash line—adds definition and helps brighten the face at any age. Waterproof formulas prevent smudging and keep the look crisp throughout the day.”
4. Revant Gel Pencil Eyeliner
- Formula: Gel pencil, smudge-proof, vegan and hypoallergenic
- Longevity: Up to 24-hour wear, safe for sensitive eyes
- Key benefits: Effortless glide, very gentle for mature or delicate skin, built-in tip sharpener
What others are reading
What reviewers say: “This liner goes on so smoothly—even after hand surgery, I can apply it left-handed. No pulling, no smudging, all-day wear.”
5. Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
- Formula: Gel pot
- Application: Brush included for versatile lines (from precise to smudgy)
- Key benefits: Intense color payoff, waterproof, easy blending during application
Note: Ideal for women who enjoy using a brush for a controlled application and creative looks.
6. Jones Road Beauty The Best Pencil
- Formula: Creamy pencil
- Benefits: Smooth application, buildable, easy to blend
- Bonus: Created by Bobbi Brown, focusing on natural, flattering enhancements
Other Top Picks Recommended by Experts and Testers
- Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner: No-tug, twists up, rich shades, blendable before set.
- L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil: Budget-friendly, long-wearing, creamy texture.
- IT Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner: Designed specifically for delicate, aging eyelids; dermatologist-tested.
- Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner: Cult favorite for its performance and trusted by makeup artists for decades.
- NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner: Felt-tip pen for easy control and precise lining, even on crepey skin.
How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Older Women
Picking the perfect eyeliner formula, color, and tip for your needs is essential. Here’s a breakdown of the top buying considerations:
1. Formula
- Long-wearing, waterproof formulas are highly recommended by professionals like Laura Geller and others. They resist transfer and smudging, even on hooded eyes or skin prone to oiliness.
- Gel and creamy pencils are ideal: They glide across the skin without pulling, blend easily, and set for all-day wear.
- Liners with nourishing ingredients (like vitamin E or jojoba oil) can also offer added hydration for dryness that develops with age.
2. Color Selection
- Dark shades (black, navy, charcoal): Best for creating definition, especially if lashes have thinned or faded.
- Browns and bronzes: Softer than black, more forgiving for daytime or subtle definition.
- Plums and deep greens: Complement brown or hazel eyes and add brightness to the whites of the eyes.
- Softer shades for the waterline: They create a natural look and prevent eyes from appearing smaller or over-lined.
3. Eyeliner Type
- Pencil eyeliner is generally the best choice. It’s easy to use, allows for soft or bold effects, and is especially forgiving for shaky hands or unsteady lines.
- Gel pencils provide blendability before setting but last all day once dry.
- Liquid liners can deliver crisp lines, but may be less forgiving on textured skin or unsteady hands.
- Twist-ups (mechanical pencils) remove the need for sharpening—suitable for those with arthritis or dexterity concerns.
What Kind of Eyeliner Is Best for Older Women?
Experts like makeup artist Emily Figueroa suggest that the soft gel pencil is the best option for mature eyes. Creamy formulas glide on easily, blend well for a softer finish, and once set, resist smudging or fading throughout the day. Pencil and gel types are typically gentler on delicate skin, with less pulling or skipping compared to firmer pencils or sharp liquids.
Makeup Artist-Approved Application Tips for Mature Eyes
- Always start with a clean, moisturized eyelid. A light eye cream or primer can help liner adhere and prevent skipping.
- Rest your elbow on a table to steady your hand if needed.
- Work in small strokes along the lash line for control, rather than trying to achieve one steady swoop.
- For a softer look, smudge the line with a brush, cotton swab, or your finger before it dries.
- Don’t pull or tug at your eyelid; this can create uneven application and emphasize fine lines.
- Use a powder shadow in similar shade to set pencil liner and add extra staying power.
- For hooded lids: Keep eyeliner thin and close to the lash line. Avoid overly thick lines, which can disappear beneath the fold.
- For a lifted effect: Extend the liner upward slightly at the outer corner for a subtle, age-defying cat eye.
Common Eyeliner Mistakes to Avoid on Mature Eyes
- Using dry or hard pencils: These can tug at delicate skin and yield uneven lines.
- Overly thick or harsh lines: Can appear stark and draw attention to wrinkles or creases.
- Neglecting the lower waterline: Using a dark liner here can make eyes look smaller; instead, opt for a nude or taupe shade to open the eyes.
- Applying to the inner corners: This can create a droopy effect. Stop liner just at the outer edge of the iris for a natural, lifted look.
FAQs: Eyeliner for Older Women
What formula should I look for if I have sensitive eyes?
Choose liners specifically labeled as hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested, or safe for sensitive eyes. Gel pencils and cream formulas—with no fragrance or harsh ingredients—are excellent choices for those prone to irritation.
How do I keep eyeliner from smudging or transferring onto hooded lids?
Opt for waterproof, long-wearing formulas and apply a light sweep of translucent powder or neutral eyeshadow to absorb oil before lining. After application, allow a few seconds for the liner to set before blinking or moving the eye.
Which color eyeliner is most flattering for mature skin?
Charcoal, brown, bronze, navy, and plum are versatile and flattering on mature skin and eyes. These shades offer definition without the harshness of jet black, which can accentuate fine lines or crepey texture.
Should I use eyeliner on my lower lash line?
Applying liner on the lower lash line can add definition, but keep the line soft and limited to the outer third of the eye. Avoid dark liner on the waterline, which may make eyes appear smaller. Opt for soft brown or taupe for the most natural effect.
What can I do if my eyeliner skips or drags on my eyelid?
Ensure your skin is well-moisturized and use a primer if desired. Choose creamy or gel-based formulas that glide on easily—these won’t tug or catch on drier, textured skin.
Quick Comparison Table: Eyeliners for Older Women
| Product | Formula | Best For | Waterproof | Shade Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On | Cream Pencil | Variety & Smooth Glide | Yes | 30+ |
| KISS New York Luxury | Cream, Twist-up | Budget, No Sharpening | Partial | 2 |
| Laura Geller INKcredible | Gel Pencil | Waterproof for Hooded Lids | Yes | Multiple |
| Revant Gel Eyeliner | Gel Pencil | Sensitive/Mature Eyes | Yes | Varies |
| Maybelline Eye Studio Gel | Gel Pot + Brush | Precision/Versatility | Yes | Several |
Expert Makeup Tips for Mature Women
- Apply eyeliner after eyeshadow for softer blending.
- Use an angled liner brush to soften lines or fix mistakes.
- Choose pencils with built-in sharpeners for added convenience—this ensures a precise tip at every use.
- Try matching your eyeliner to your mascara shade for a seamless look.
- Don’t forget your brows! Well-groomed brows frame the face and complement defined eyes.
Conclusion: Your Best Eye Forward at Any Age
The right eyeliner can be transformative for mature women, whether you want subtle enhancement or eye-catching drama. Opt for creamy, waterproof pencils in flattering shades, and don’t shy away from trying new techniques. With these expert-recommended picks and easy tips, you’re just a swipe away from gorgeous, confidently defined eyes—no matter your age.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Are gel eyeliners better than pencils for mature skin?
A: Gel eyeliners, especially in pencil form, are usually best for mature skin as they glide on easily, avoid tugging, and deliver bold color that sets for long-lasting wear.
Q: How can I get a natural-looking eyeliner effect?
A: Use a soft brown, bronze, or plum pencil and blend the line gently with a brush or cotton swab before it sets for a subtle, smudged look that softly defines the eyes.
Q: What is the easiest eyeliner for unsteady or arthritic hands?
A: Twist-up cream or gel pencils are the most forgiving. They’re soft, don’t require sharpening, and can be smudged for a less precise line, making mistakes easier to correct.
Q: Should older women avoid black eyeliner?
A: Black liner can still look beautiful if applied subtly close to the lashes, but softer shades like brown or charcoal are typically more flattering for daytime or a natural look.
Q: How can I prevent eyeliner from bleeding into fine lines?
A: Choose a waterproof formula and set the lines with matching powder eyeshadow. Applying a lightweight eye primer before lining also helps lock in color and reduce transfer.
References
Similar Articles
Read full bio of medha deb
